WPCz K!8 Z:YٶS50+gtAvfO6ꇹ!;d@{:? "IȨj7vy<{M4!v6GtҤM؆ai7)F1ܛܲ3XWޖuF80~WM9΍rY/ Th*4"t*#:RMK]Ud2&e{bidd7NT5Yŗu!b^ tnUcLlBfG:svdHpw:F袰 C̾o6uH;CEZ|1) 0~ 0x& 0k 0k  0t 0~ 0 0] 0A 0 0  0 01 0C7! 0Vz" 0# 0$ 0C% 0% 0& 0f' 0!( 0( 0)UV@* %* 0z* 0+ + 01A , 0TL, 0h, 1- 0- 1t. 0y/00 0O3E!4U:#4 A]4 D+4%5 0O5 0C:6 AM}667 AV8 189 0J|: AM: C;-; 0C; 0O6< AS<<nY< 04A@ B#u@N@w@@4@UN@n6A B*9CncC@fEBFos_ FF? BQ n UB N f a  0O ff ah  | n  '  .ȭ nZ  P n]  n f M n n  M 0< M\ ` 0` 0^ 0< 0$ 0 0 0 0& 0A 06 0/T 0 0 0 06 0 0V 0 0x 0 0 0( 0 0L 0 0p 0 0 0& 0 0M 0 0t 0U n[ _ a_ fs U :u  U.i a U@ 0* n D3 CK e fe fg ai B} f a f a a f a n   fH 0PJ f a a n s ns v nv y ny ( n( B 0   H  n  n N f a f a M M f a f0 a2 0F   n f a U.> N* f, a. fB aD BX Mw f{ a} f a N nZ   n  n  n  n  f a f a n    9 f; a= fQ aS Mg D3k f a n # n# n' 1u+ 0d5, , , 0P, , , B , M- M- f- 0N- fi- ak- a- N- nY- 0 0 1 N1 f1 1 1 91 fX5 fZ5 a\5 fp5 ar5 M5 n5 9 n9 a= = = M= = = f= a= f= ^ = = a= f= m= f= a= f> a> f)> a+> @?> oF,W> ajajfjajNjjjjjjjjjjjNjNjjjjjjjMjMjMjMjj9kfAoaCo#!WofxpazpzpzpfpapfpapNpppMpMpMpp9pfuauf.ua0u0u0ufDuaFuFuFuFuFuZuZuZu9qufyayfyayyyfyayNyyyMyMyyyyyNyyyyyyyMyMyV& 8Document[8]Document Style0..8` ..` V8Document[4]Document Style.. . V 8Document[6]Document Style8..V 8Document[5]Document Style0..V/8Document[2]Document Style 2A.3  Ԁ   V& 8Document[7]Document Style0..0` ..` zU :Right Par[1]Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbers..2I.3  Ԁ..0..zh :Right Par[2]Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbers..` ..2A.3  Ԁ..0` ..` V?8Document[3]Document Style.. 21.3  Ԁ   z{ :Right Par[3]Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbers..` ..`  ..P 21.3  Ԁ` ..` 0 .. z :Right Par[4]Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbers..` ..`  .. .. 2a.3  Ԁ .. 0..z :Right Par[5]Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbers..` ..`  .. ..h..2(1)3  Ԁ..0h..hz :Right Par[6]Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbers..` ..`  .. ..h..h..2(a)3  Ԁh..h0..z :Right Par[7]Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbers..` ..`  .. ..h..h....2i)3  Ԁ..0..z :Right Par[8]Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbers..` ..`  .. ..h..h....p..2a)3  Ԁ..0p..pVX8Document[1]Document Style  @..^  2I.3  Ԁ     Ԉ l2:Technical[5]Technical Document Style.. 2(1)3  Ԁ. l2:Technical[6]Technical Document Style.. 2(a)3  Ԁ. l/%:Technical[2]Technical Document Style 2A.3  Ԁ   .. l,!:Technical[3]Technical Document Style 21.3  Ԁ   .. l(!:Technical[4]Technical Document Style 2a.3  Ԁ   .. l:0:Technical[1]Technical Document Style  2I.3  Ԁ     .. l1:Technical[7]Technical Document Style.. 2i)3  Ԁ. l1:Technical[8]Technical Document Style.. 2a)3  Ԁ. 2 Ha`$>Letter Gothic 12cpi25inOne!BXR& 8BibliogrphyBibliography0....fp2Doc InitInitialize Document StyleS !    I. 1. A. a.(1)(a) i) a)S (Vm$0   (,!$0  0` (#(#  (@$0  0` (#(#0 ` (#` (# `   A_ekqwDocumentDocument StyleI.1.A.a.(1)(a)i)a)jo4Tech InitInitialize Technical StyleS #  1 .1 .1 .1 .1 .1 .1 .1 S CuyTechnicalTechnical Document Style11.11.1.11.1.1.11.1.1.1.11.1.1.1.1.11.1.1.1.1.1.11.1.1.1.1.1.1.1x?t2PleadingHeader for numbered pleading paper %  &(   XXXXX?>''*dE*??>''*dE*?HH1HH2HH3HH4HH5HH6HH7HH8HH910111213141516171819202122232425262728  .+('2$ =T!   <6X9`("Courier 12cpi3,4* I&mage <=8C HKKKK'dxd Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Level 4 Level 5('2$ =T!   ($     +,-*A<< cLevel 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5Level 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 53,4*&OLE 2.0 Box <=8C HKKKK  CRight ParRight-Aligned Paragraph NumbersI.A.1.a.(1)(a)i)a) Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Level 4 Level 5("$ Figure    3,4*A<< c d Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Level 4 Level 5($     ('2$ =T!   79,8*6C<< c3|dF2 Ha`$>Letter Gothic 12cpi25inOne!X&d H@QX@<6X9`("Courier 12cpipi25inOne!d6X@8;@,xA`&UniversScalable25inOne!xP7P,xA`&UniversScalable25inOne!TxP7P,xA`&UniversScalable25inOne!XX~xP7XP( T$   d =>?P@PABPCDPEFRY-z(9 Z 6Times New Roman Regular2 Ha`$>Letter Gothic 12cpi25inOne!X&d H@QX@* `(CG TimesScalable25inOne!   P7 P<6X9`("Courier 12cpile25inOne!d6X@8;@&0 d d2 Ha`$>Letter Gothic 12cpi25inOne!X&d H@QX@* `(CG TimesScalable25inOne!   P7 P<6X9`("Courier 12cpile25inOne!d6X@8;@HC:\1FILES\BUSINE~1\SAMI\CLIENTS\WAGROU~1\STUDYD~1\CD\SAMIUSE\VSTL6\VEWS.TIF 88((dXXd8WPCX0*X0*X0* CX0*}J&?%$#" " ! ?!  ? ?????   ?     !!"""""?"?"""""""###$$$ $    ? ?   ?   ?  ? ?  ?      ?        ?       ?           ? ?? ?   ????????????2T(+?+--?--../////?/?//0001J!&%$#?#" " ! ! !  ??????    ?          !""""?"?""""     ?    ? ? ?? ? ? ?        ? ? ?      ? ?       ? ? ?? ? ? ? ?      ?   """"""?"?""""!         ?  ????????   ?! ! " " " ?#$$%&J(99888888887777664!       !!!!!!!!""""""""######??........---?--????2T'*+,,--...?.?..///0000J+.--,,?+++*** * * ) )          ?           ?    ? ?????????       ?  ?  ?  ?  ? ?   ?                  ?                  ?   ?  ?  ?  ?  ?  ?  ?  ?  ?  ? ? ?  ? ?   ?   ?   ?   ?           ?   ?         ?           ?             ?? ? ?        ?          ?   ??      ? ?                 ?                  ? %&?&'J99888888887????  ?         ?         ?             ?        ?   ?????????? ? !!!!!!! ! " " ?" " " " " " # # # # # ?# ##$$?$$$$$$ % % % % %? % % % & & & & & & &? & ' ' ' ' ' ' '? ' ( ( ( ( ( (2T$)?*,?,---...?.../////00J-?,,+++++?*******)?)?)))))))))))))))?)?))*******?**+++++++?++,,,,,,,,,,,,,?????? "S???  J,&%$#?#" " ! ! !  ??????    ?          !""""?"?""""     ?    ? ? ?? ? ? ?        ? ? ?      ? ?       ? ? ?? ? ? ? ?      ?   """"""?"?""""!         ?  ????????   ?! ! " " " ?#$$%&JAAAAA@?@@@@@@@?????>?>>>====<<<?;;;?:::999888 7 7 7 6 6 6 5 5 5 4 4 4333?32221110?0?0// / . . . - - - , , , ?+ + + ?* * *?)))?(((?'''?&&&?%%%?$$$?###?"""?!!!    !!!"""###$$$%%%&&&'''((((''' & & & % % % $$$###"""!!!    ???                     ?    ?     ?     ?     ?     ?     ?   ?   ?    ?       ? !$$$###"""!!!      !!!"""###$$$%%?%&&?&''?'((?())?)**?*++?+,,?,---...///....?---,,,++ + ?+ ?* * ?* ) ) ?) ) ( ?( ( ?' ?' '&& & & ?% % % $ $$$?###?"""!!!!?  ? ????? ?       ?     ??###"""?"!!!   ?               ?    ?   ?         ??????$###"""!!!?!      !!!!"""##?#$$$%%%%&&&''?'((?())))***++?+,,?,---....//?/00?01112222 3 3 3 4 4 ?4 5 5 5 6 6 6 6 7 7 788?8999::::;;?;<<<<====>>>>??????@@@@@@?@@AAAAAJ.--,,?+++*** * * ) )          ?           ?    ? ?????????       ?  ?  ?  ?  ? ?   ?                  ?                  ?   ?  ?  ?  ?  ?  ?  ?  ?  ?  ? ? ?  ? ?   ?   ?   ?   ?           ?   ?         ?           ?             ?? ? ?        ?          ?   ??      ? ?                 ?                  ? %&?&'J&%$#?""!   ??                ?              ?                ?                 ?             ? ?     ? ?  ?                      ? ?  ?   ?   ?   ?   ?             ?   ?                                                ?   ?   ?                            ?     ?   ?   ?   ?  ?  ?       ?          ? """"!!?!?!!    ???????   !! ! " " ?# $ $%'J%211111?11??????         ?? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?? ? ?          ? ?    ?        ?         ? ? ? ? ? ?             ?                  ? ?             ?  ?  ?  ? ? ?  ?              ? ?     """""?!?!!!!      ?????????   ! ! ! " " ?# # ?$%%'J998888888877 * ) (?'%"""""""""?"""""" " " ?" " " " " "  " " " " ?" " """"""?"""""""""""?  ?  ???  J1110?0000000//////?....----,,,,?+++****?)))((( ( ?' ' ' & & & & ?%%%$$$$###?"?"?"!!!!?         ?        &&?'''((()?)))***+?++,,,,--,,?,,+++* * ?* * ) ) ) ((?(('''&&&&% % % $ $ $ $ #                ???????????    !!!"""" # # # $ $ $ $ % % ?% & & & & ' ' ?' (((())?)****++++,,,,----...?.//////000000?00111J-?,,+++++?*******)?)?)))))))))))))))?)?))*******?**+++++++?++,,,,,,,,,,,,,?????? "S???  J$%$#?""!   ??                ?              ?                ?                 ?             ? ?     ? ?  ?                      ? ?  ?   ?   ?   ?   ?             ?   ?                                                ?   ?   ?                            ?     ?   ?   ?   ?  ?  ?       ?          ? """"!!?!?!!    ???????   !! ! " " ?# $ $%'J.*)((?''&&& ?% % % % ?$ $ $ $ ?######?""      ?       ?             ?      ?    ? ?   ? ??????? ?          ?       ?  ?       ?                    ?   ? ?  ? ? ? ?  ? ?                            ?       ?  ?  ?  ?               ?                  ?  ?  ?                              ?      ?   ?   ?   ?   ? ?   ?              ?  ?                    ?  ?      ?  ? ? ??  ?   ??????????       ?       ?       ?  ?                   ?         ?   ?                   ' J%$#?""!   ??                ?              ?                ?                 ?             ? ?     ? ?  ?                      ? ?  ?   ?   ?   ?   ?             ?   ?                                                ?   ?   ?                            ?     ?   ?   ?   ?  ?  ?       ?          ? """"!!?!?!!    ???????   !! ! " " ?# $ $%'J+99888888887777664"T????????55555666666?6?666666665 5 5? 5? 5? 5? 5? 4 4 4 4 3 3 1 # # # #? # #""""""?""!!!!!!?!!     ?  ??,.?.///000000?00111J998888888877776642T'**,?,---...?...////00J55555?544444?5555555?555566666?65555555543 ??!!!!!!!!"""""""!"""""""""?#?##""""""?""!!!!?!   ??   ?   ?          ? ?  ? ?                ?   ?                 ??  ?? ? ?  ?  ?  ?  ?  ?  ? ? ?? ? ? ? ?? ?   ?      ?    ???????? ? ?                                              ? ? ? ?             ? ?       ? ?    001122J!AAAAA@?@@@@@@@?????????>?>>>>>>=====<<<<<?;;;;::::9999888 8 ?7 7 7 7 6 6 6 5 5 5 5 ?4443333??2222?1110000??/?/ / . . . . ?- - - - , , , + + ++?***))))?(((('''&&&&?%%%$$$$?####"" " ! !!!!!!? ! " ""###?#$$$%%%%&&&?&'''(((?()))*******?)))( ( ( ( ?' ' ' & & & %%%%$?$$####"?""!!!                 ??  ?          ?     ??????!!!?       !!!!""?"####$$?$%%%%&&?&'''(((())?)****++?+,,,,--?-...////00?0111122?2 3 3 3 4 4 4 4 5 5 ?5 6 6 6 6 7 7 ?7 888899?9::::;;;;<<?<===?=>>>>>?????@@@@@@?@@AAAAAJ00/////.?.?.....---,?,,,+**(&2c&(*++,,?,,---....?../////00J00//////.?.?.....---,?,,,+**(&2c(())()))?((('((''''?&& & % % % % $ $ $ ?# $ $ # # # # """?!!!    ??,,++++***?)))((((?'''?&&&%%%%?$$$?###"""" ?! ! !! ! ! !"""#?##$$$$%%%&?&&'''(((((?'''& & & & % % % ?$ $ $$###"""?!!!!   ??????? ?       ?       ? ! !!!""?"###$$$?$%%%&&&&''?'(((())?)****++?+,??  ?    ! ! ! ?! " " " # # # # $ $ ?$ % % % %&%?%&&&&''?'''''('?'('&2&(?)**++?++,-------?--.//////////00 J998888888877777777666665555544444333322211110000 / / / . . . . - - - , , , , + + + ****)))(((('''&&&&%%%$$$$###""""!!!       !!!!??      ?                                 x      ? ????                                    ?        ???           ?       ???     ?              !8 ! ! ! " " " " # # # $ $ $ $? % % % & & & &''''?((())))?***++++ , , , - - - - . . . . / / / 0 00011112222333344444555556666666777777778888888899J*)((?''&&& ?% % % % ?$ $ $ $ ?######?""      ?       ?             ?      ?    ? ?   ? ??????? ?          ?       ?  ?       ?                    ?   ? ?  ? ? ? ?  ? ?                            ?       ?  ?  ?  ?               ?                  ?  ?  ?                              ?      ?   ?   ?   ?   ? ?   ?              ?  ?                    ?  ?      ?  ? ? ??  ?   ??????????       ?       ?       ?  ?                   ?         ?   ?                   ' J??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????x??????????????8?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&qMtɚu!y5%\т})-Dj15,Ry9=:aAE"IIpM 1QX~UY@g] a( Ouei 7 ] m  q  E ul ! ͹ y % - }T ){ ա -  < X0*Rq] R)\  (F@C:\1FILES\BUSINE~1\SAMI\CLIENTS\WAGROU~1\STUDYD~1\CD\SAMIUSE\VSTL6\VEWS.TIFC:\1files\businesses\sami\clients\WA Group\study docs\cd\samiuse\vstl6\vews.tifLAP7Pܴ @ ޅܴb7PܴG87P 7P-goG,CK Kd2 Ha`$>Letter Gothic 12cpi25inOne!X&d H@QX@* `(CG TimesScalable25inOne!   P7 P<6X9`("Courier 12cpile25inOne!d6X@8;@\  `*Times New RomanTTTable_A('2$ =T!   Table_A2 Ha`$>Letter Gothic 12cpi25inOne!X&d H@QX@* `(CG TimesScalable25inOne!   P7 P<6X9`("Courier 12cpile25inOne!d6X@8;@  Q'   _HT@@` 0Pp @ `"XTB !XBX@VV,TABLEOFCONTENTS#BX X!B ؙ#BZXBX Y $_Thispageisatemplateforgenerationofthetableofcontents.Avoideditingthispage.Placethispageimmediatelyafterthetitlepage. EditthetitleintheheaderAsectiononlyforthe  correspondingtableofcontentstitleappearance. 2 Ha`$>Letter Gothic 12cpi25inOne!X&d H@QX@<\( 9`("Courier NewTTpi25inOne!d\( @E@0|A`$ArialTTTTpi25inOne!H|@E@C\( 9`("Courier NewTTpi25inOne!d\( @E@* `(CG TimesScalable25inOne!   P7 P* `(CG TimesScalable25inOne! P7P) `(CG TimesScalable25inOne!c P7P<6X9`("Courier 12cpile25inOne!d6X@8;@1<6X9`("Courier 10cpiXx6X@8;X@* `(CG TimesScalable P7P* `(CG TimesScalable   P7 P,xA`&UniversScalablexP7P,xA`&UniversScalablexx&xP7xP,xA`&UniversScalableLLxP7LP<6X9`("Courier 12cpied6X@8;@<6X9`("Courier 10cpiXx6X@8;X@* `(CG TimesScalable   P7 P<6X9`("Courier 12cpiled6X@8;@<6X9`("Courier 10cpiXx6X@8;X@* `(CG TimesScalable   P7 P<6X9`("Courier 12cpiled6X@8;@2 Ha`$>Letter Gothic 12cpi25inOne!X&d H@QX@<\( 9`("Courier NewTTpi25inOne!d\( @E@3|A`$ArialTTTTpi25inOne!H|@E@C\( 9`("Courier NewTTpi25inOne!d\( @ E@* `(CG TimesScalable25inOne!   P7 P<6X9`("Courier 12cpile25inOne!d6X@8;@<:Default Para<:Drawing listO<\( 9`("Courier NewTTO @   D        42drawingsO<\( 9`("Courier NewTTO @l        86SubmittalsC3|A`$ArialTTC&hh0!#% '&        64AmendmentO<\( 9`("Courier NewTTO ,   42contentsO<\( 9`("Courier NewTTO @lT     #)d#      fI2LOS HeadList of Submittals Header    X6Basic specBasic spec styleO<\( 9`("Courier NewTTO     4`    &$18DC ScheduleInsert at Bidding Schedule - ConstructionOC\( 9`("Courier NewTTO       hTx0L8Drawing NUMFor use in "DRAWINGS IN NUMERICAL ORDER"O<\( 9`("Courier NewTTO <`   h    8DS ScheduleInsert at Bidding Schedule - SupplyO<\( 9`("Courier NewTTO     h     :V8OmniPage #1 x`   P  x# 0..:Y8OmniPage #2 x   P   0..:V8OmniPage #4 x  1 P  T 0..:V8OmniPage #3 x}    P  [ 0..:V8OmniPage #5 x    U   0..:V8OmniPage #6 x'   P   0..<V:OmniPage #11 x   P   0..:V8OmniPage #7 x1   P   0..:V8OmniPage #8 x0   P   0..:V8OmniPage #9 x   P   0..<V:OmniPage #10 x    U   0..<V:OmniPage #25 x\   P  }# 0..<V:OmniPage #12 x    U   0..<V:OmniPage #13 x$   P   0..<V:OmniPage #14 x   P  >& 0..<V:OmniPage #15 x   P  " 0..<V:OmniPage #26       [ 0..<Y:OmniPage #51 x)S   %   0..<V:OmniPage #52 x   P  M 0..<Y:OmniPage #76 6    3   0..<V:OmniPage #77 x   P   0..<V:OmniPage #78 x  S P  # 0..>$"Small Circle"0..2 Ha`$>Letter Gothic 12cpi25inOne!X&d H@QX@<\( 9`("Courier NewTTpi25inOne!d\( @E@3|A`$ArialTTTTpi25inOne!H|@E@C\( 9`("Courier NewTTpi25inOne!d\( @ E@* `(CG TimesScalable25inOne!   P7 P<6X9`("Courier 12cpile25inOne!d6X@8;@Table_A<\( 9`("Courier NewTT  Q'   XXXX:F'4` X'@Table____.-ListofsubmittalsContinued  ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________̀||||||̀||Reference|Respon-||No.ofsetsto|3Duedateor 8 RSN|Item|provision,|sible|Submittalsrequired|besentto:*|deliverytime * Ѐ||clause,or|code||CO|1(PCE)|DO| | Ѐ||paragraph||||(CE)||̀||||||(PM)||_____|______________________|__________|_______|_____________________|____|______|____|____________________||||||||3|A`$ArialTTTable_A* `(CG TimesScalable($<6X9`("Courier 10cpiXx6X@8;X@* `(CG TimesScalable   P7 P<6X9`("Courier 12cpiled6X@8;@DDDD'dxdddTable_AK KdTABLE CLetter Gothic 12cpi25inOne!X&d H@QX@* `(CG TimesScalable25inOne!   P7 P<6X9`("Courier 12cpile25inOne!d6X@8;@* `(CG TimesScalable25inOne! P7P Ϳ)   _Draft10/25/2002StudyforUSArmyCorpsofEngineersBaltimoreDistrict((3Ϳ$ =T!   Table_ATABLE B2 Ha`$>Letter Gothic 12cpi25inOne!X&d H@QX@<\( 9`("Courier NewTTpi25inOne!d\( @E@0|A`$ArialTTTTpi25inOne!H|@E@C\( 9`("Courier NewTTpi25inOne!d\( @E@* `(CG TimesScalable25inOne!   P7 P<6X9`("Courier 12cpile25inOne!d6X@8;@,xA`&UniversScalable25inOne!_xP7P<6X9`("Courier 10cpiXx6X@8;X@* `(CG TimesScalable   P7 P<6X9`("Courier 12cpiled6X@8;@<6X9`("Courier 10cpiXx6X@8;X@* `(CG TimesScalable   P7 P<6X9`("Courier 12cpiled6X@8;@2 Ha`$>Letter Gothic 12cpi25inOne!X&d H@QX@<\( 9`("Courier NewTTpi25inOne!d\( @E@3|A`$ArialTTTTpi25inOne!H|@E@C\( 9`("Courier NewTTpi25inOne!d\( @ E@* `(CG TimesScalable25inOne!   P7 P<6X9`("Courier 12cpile25inOne!d6X@8;@* `(CG TimesScalable25inOne! P7P2 Ha`$>Letter Gothic 12cpi25inOne!X&d H@QX@<\( 9`("Courier NewTTpi25inOne!d\( @E@0|A`$ArialTTTTpi25inOne!H|@E@C\( 9`("Courier NewTTpi25inOne!d\( @E@* `(CG TimesScalable25inOne!   P7 P<6X9`("Courier 12cpile25inOne!d6X@8;@,xA`&UniversScalable25inOne!_xP7P  dH&&4HyperlinkHyperlink             DETRICK CVS CVT FWHA UEPHDetrickunenlistedwilliam zzzthoughoutteram search,replaceformating EIFS PTACUSACEnonenlisted<6X9`("Courier 10cpiXx6X@8;X@* `(CG TimesScalable   P7 P<6X9`("Courier 12cpiled6X@8;@<6X9`("Courier 10cpiXx6X@8;X@* `(CG TimesScalable   P7 P<6X9`("Courier 12cpiled6X@8;@Table_ATable_BTable_CTable_E`:footnote reffootnote reference        ԫ2 Ha`$>Letter Gothic 12cpi25inOne!X&d H@QX@<\( 9`("Courier NewTTpi25inOne!d\( @E@3|A`$ArialTTTTpi25inOne!H|@E@C\( 9`("Courier NewTTpi25inOne!d\( @ E@* `(CG TimesScalable25inOne!   P7 P<6X9`("Courier 12cpile25inOne!d6X@8;@Table_A\  `&Times New RomanTable_ATable_B1  dTable_DTable_E2 Ha`$>Letter Gothic 12cpi25inOne!X&d H@QX@* `(CG TimesScalable25inOne! P7P,xA`&UniversScalable25inOne!xP7P<6X9`("Courier 12cpie25inOne!d6X@8;@* `(CG TimesScalable25inOne!   P7 P,xA`&UniversScalable25inOne!XX~xP7XP,xA`&UniversScalable25inOne!,,?xP7,P-xA`&UniversScalable25inOne!5xP7P2 Ha`$>Letter Gothic 12cpi25inOne!X&d H@QX@<\( 9`("Courier NewTTpi25inOne!d\( @E@3|A`$ArialTTTTpi25inOne!H|@E@C\( 9`("Courier NewTTpi25inOne!d\( @ E@* `(CG TimesScalable25inOne!   P7 P<6X9`("Courier 12cpile25inOne!d6X@8;@2 Ha`$>Letter Gothic 12cpi25inOne!X&d H@QX@<\( 9`("Courier NewTTpi25inOne!d\( @E@0|A`$ArialTTTTpi25inOne!H|@E@C\( 9`("Courier NewTTpi25inOne!d\( @E@* `(CG TimesScalable25inOne!   P7 P<6X9`("Courier 12cpile25inOne!d6X@8;@,xA`&UniversScalable25inOne!_xP7P<6X9`("Courier 10cpiXx6X@8;X@* `(CG TimesScalable   P7 P<6X9`("Courier 12cpiled6X@8;@<6X9`("Courier 10cpiXx6X@8;X@* `(CG TimesScalable   P7 P<6X9`("Courier 12cpiled6X@8;@Table_ATable_B<6X9`("Courier 10cpiXx6X@8;X@+_ 0CG TimesBoldScalable_ p^7<6X9`("Courier 12cpialabled6X@8;@ /_ Noticetouser: (Thiscommentitemwillnotprintorshowupatallinfinalprintout.)  Togetintothetable,pressthedownorrightarrow.UsetheTABkeyormousetomovewithinthetable.(InatableTABmovesyouforwardinthetable,SHIFTTABmovesyoubackwardsinthetable.HOMEthenTABorCTRLTABwillgiveatabwithinthetable.) Savethefileas0000thefirstfourlettersinyourfirstname,pp-theideapagesheetnumber  (01,02,10,etc),andii-theideanumberonthatpage. Forexample:ifnameiswilliam,idea xx numberhasbeenlistedasI5.20,thenthefilenamewouldbeWILL05.20andtheideanumberzzzwouldbe05.20thoughoutthestudy(untilthevaluestudyteramassignsanewnumberinreport).Youcanusesearch,replacetochangetheprojectnameBigCreekRoad/CAPFH195-1(1)/HuntingtonLakeRoadtotheactualprojectnameandzzztotheideanumberspecification.Pleasedonotremovetemplateformatingfromtopsofpages.Table_BTable_CJJJJ'dxdTable_A2 Ha`$>Letter Gothic 12cpi25inOne!X&d H@QX@<\( 9`("Courier NewTTpi25inOne!d\( @E@3|A`$ArialTTTTpi25inOne!H|@E@C\( 9`("Courier NewTTpi25inOne!d\( @ E@* `(CG TimesScalable25inOne!   P7 P<6X9`("Courier 12cpile25inOne!d6X@8;@2 Ha`$>Letter Gothic 12cpi25inOne!X&d H@QX@<\( 9`("Courier NewTTpi25inOne!d\( @E@0|A`$ArialTTTTpi25inOne!H|@E@C\( 9`("Courier NewTTpi25inOne!d\( @E@* `(CG TimesScalable25inOne!   P7 P<6X9`("Courier 12cpile25inOne!d6X@8;@2 Ha`$>Letter Gothic 12cpi25inOne!X&d H@QX@<\( 9`("Courier NewTTpi25inOne!d\( @E@3|A`$ArialTTTTpi25inOne!H|@E@C\( 9`("Courier NewTTpi25inOne!d\( @ E@* `(CG TimesScalable25inOne!   P7 P<6X9`("Courier 12cpile25inOne!d6X@8;@##37=CIQYag1.a.i.(1)(a)(i)1)a)(Wh$ @3  A ((3Ϳ$ =T!   d@ (O$Table_ATable_D<6X9`("Courier 10cpiXx6X@8;X@<6X9`("Courier 12cpid6X@8;@* `(CG TimesScalable   P7 P* `(CG TimesScalable P7P) `(CG TimesScalable&&m P7&P  t /_ Noticetouser: (Thiscommentitemwillnotprintorshowupatallinfinalprintout.)  Togetintothetable,pressthedownorrightarrow.UsetheTABkeyormousetomovewithinthetable.(InatableTABmovesyouforwardinthetable,SHIFTTABmovesyoubackwardsinthetable.HOMEthenTABorCTRLTABwillgiveatabwithinthetable.) Savethefileas0000thefirstfourlettersinyourfirstname,pp-theideapagesheetnumber  (01,02,10,etc),andii-theideanumberonthatpage. Forexample:ifnameiswilliam,idea xx numberhasbeenlistedasI5.20,thenthefilenamewouldbeWILL05.20andtheideanumberzzzwouldbe05.20thoughoutthestudy(untilthevaluestudyteramassignsanewnumberinreport).Youcanusesearch,replacetochangetheprojectnameBigCreekRoad/CAPFH195-1(1)/HuntingtonLakeRoadtotheactualprojectnameandzzztotheideanumberspecification.Pleasedonotremovetemplateformatingfromtopsofpages.Table_BTable_C2 Ha`$>Letter Gothic 12cpi25inOne!X&d H@QX@<\( 9`("Courier NewTTpi25inOne!d\( @E@0|A`$ArialTTTTpi25inOne!H|@E@C\( 9`("Courier NewTTpi25inOne!d\( @E@* `(CG TimesScalable25inOne!   P7 P<6X9`("Courier 12cpipi25inOne!d6X@8;@2 Ha`$>Letter Gothic 12cpi25inOne!X&d H@QX@<\( 9`("Courier NewTTpi25inOne!d\( @E@0|A`$ArialTTTTpi25inOne!H|@E@C\( 9`("Courier NewTTpi25inOne!d\( @E@* `(CG TimesScalable25inOne!   P7 P<6X9`("Courier 12cpile25inOne!d6X@8;@TABLE ETable_AY-Table_AUTable_ATABLE ATable_A1DESC.PCXWPCtD*tD*9513tD*,, +] }MUUUUUUzUf?U fUfUfUf Uf Uf? Uf? Uf?? Uf?? Ul?0 Ul?|?Ǐ??? Ul`> ? Ul~<x? Ul~>|? Uc~0~|?Uc2?Uc'??Uc/?UcO? Uc_? Uc_? Uc?? U c U c? Uc Uc?? Uc|? T?c|; T?c ; T?j~w T?jx/? T?j T?jq T?j? Tj&Tj&Tk&Uk&Uk&Uk&Uk&T@k&Tk&T@k&Tj&T@?j&Tj&Tj&TjSw`sjS jSqwjSiSww?i Si S?i Si Rwsi Ri Rqwi? Rh?> Rww?h< Rh?x>8? Rh<>0 Rh`??>f` Qwsh ??~n Qh ??|N Qqwh?  Qg?? Qww?g?| Qg?| Qg? Qg Pwsg Pg? Pqwg? Pf<? Pww?f~|9? Pf~;~> Pf7~~ Pf'~ Owsf??? Of Oqwf?Oe&Ow w?e&O e&O e&O e&Nw se&N e&Nq we&N d&Nw w?d&N d&N d&N d&Mw sd&M d&Mq wd&M c&Mw w?c&M c&M c&Mc&Mw sc&Lc&Lqwc&Lb&Lw?b&Lb&Lßb&Lb&L;sb&Kb&K8wb&Ka&Kw?a&Ka&KÏa&Ka&K;sa&Ja&J8wa&J`&Jw?`&J`&JÏ`&J`&J;s`&I`&I8w`&I_&Iw?_&I_&IÏ_&I_&I;s_&H_&H^&Hw?^&H^&HÏ ^&H ^&G8? s^&G ^&G q^&G^&Gw]&G ^&G ]&G<? ]&F;? w]&F ]&Fq]&F??]&F<|?w\&F???]&F?\&F???\&E ;??w\&E ?\&E ?q\&E ?\&E!?w[&E ?\&E!8?[&E!??[&D";???w[&D"??[&D"?q[&D"χ?[&D#?wZ&D"??[&D#?Z&D#??;Z&C$;??3wZ&C$<|?Z&C$ <qZ&C |Z&C wY&C!Z&C!Y&C?!Y&B;"wݗ&B"wv&B"qݗ&B"wv&B"wݗ&B#6&B#??6&B?#ݟ6&A;$?6&A$6&A$?6&A$6&A$?6&A%;?&A%?? &A?% &@;? &@?? ?&@??&@?&@?&@ ;&@ ??&@? &?; ?&? 'ϟϟ|?&? ?( >p?&? ( 8 `&?,?|??(>`G&?,|?p??;( ? ?~&?-8| p??`<??(??&?-?p1?c8?`G>?(?&>.;'?O?~?.????|(&>.???|?(&>.??>(?&>.??>?(?&>.??;(?&>)????(?ǃ&>)??? (?&=;$?? ?(&=$???(|?&=$?????(|?&=$???(?&=$?? ??(??&=$?? ;(???&=$?? ??(?&=?$?? (??&<;$?? ?(< x?&<$???~ )`8&<$??8 ?? &<%?? $&<%p8 ?$&< ?;$&</??$&<?/$&;;0?$&;0$&;0?$&;0$&;0?#&;0;#&;1??6&;?16&:;2?6&:2?6&:2?6&:2?6 &:2?6 &:26 &:ß2?6 &:?26 &:ÿ2? 0:3 0:Ï3?? 0:? ;?` 0:?? ? 0:?? 8?0:8?? ?0:? ?0;;? ?0;?? Ï?0;Ï?? >0;?? ;?0;?? >3~??ϟ?|0;?? 8?:0?p??p~~0;8?? : >?` ǃǃ|?x?`>p>0;$?????:<G>@<80<;$???A:>?y? ~?^|??0<$|?????x?x?Ï:????????0<Ï$??{8???8?:>??????0<$??????;:???0<%???????:>???0<%??????8:???0<8%?????:>???0<+?????:???0=*;?????:>??Ã?0=%????Ï:???0=*Ï????:>????0=*??8??;:??????0=*????:>???|??0=*?????8:???0=*8?????:>??0=*?????:??0>);????:>?}?0>)????Ï:?;?~0>)Ï????:>?x??0>)>?????;: ?|???0>/?<?;??: >?8p0>.??3???8| >??0>.8|???@??60>.p<p60? ; ?60?*Ï60?Ï)?60?);60?(?60?(860?8(?60?'60@;'?60@(Ï60@Ï'?60@';60@&?60@&860@8&?60@%60A;%?60A&Ï60AÏ%?60A%;60A%?60A$860A8 ??60A 60B; ?60B ?60BÏ ?ݗ0B ?wv0B ?wݗ0B ?wv0B8 ?wݗ0B  ?C;  sC  CÏ???ϟ?CC  w?C8?? wC?D;sDDÏDDw?D D8wDE;sE?EÏ?E?E?w?EE8wE~?F;sF`FÏ????FFw?FF8wFG;sGGÏGGw?GG9wGG;wH?HHHwHHqHH;wI?IIIwIIqII;wJ?JJJwJJqJJ;wK?KKKwKKqKK;wLLLLwLLqLLwwM M? M M wM Ms qM Mw wM Nw? N N wN Ns qN Nw wN Ow? O OwOOsqOOwwOPw?PPwPPsqPPwwPQw?QQwQQsqQQwwQRw?RRwRRsqRRwwRSw?SSwSSsqSSwwSTw?TT~wTT`qTT`wTU`UUU U8UUUU?UUUUU U ?U  U <U |U |U ?<U ?<U ~U U U U U U U ?U ?U w?U U U U U UUSSSSSSSSTT?T?TTTTTTTTTTTTTT?U?U9;wx9݈w9;wx9݈w9;wx9w9?x96w9?6x96w9?6x96w9?6x96w9? $x9$w9?$x9?`$w9??$x9? w9?? x9? w9?? x9? w9?? x9? w9??>p|x99?p??w98???x?`|<<x99??8@x>w98???^x99????w98??????x99??~???w98????x99???w98????x99??~Aw98???~x99??~w98???~?x99?|~w98?~|?x99>?|??w98?>??x99>??w98??x??xx99q?x~~w98??8~x99|???w98??0?px9 ?? x? ?w9?x9w9?x9w9?x9w9?x9w9?x9w9? x96w9?6x96w9?6x96w9?6x96w9?6x96w9?6x9.?w9?-x9-w9?-x9.?w9?x9?w9??x9?w9??x9?w9??x99?~??w98?x?>?x99ǃ`?<w98??`??8|?x99??G??w98??????x99?????w98???x99??w98????x93????w93??????x93????w93?????x93???w93????x99?~???w98??????x99??????w98????????x99????>w98???x99??w98?>x99??@p?w9?p?|?x9w9?x9w9?x9w9?x9w9?x9w9??x9w9?6x96w9?6x96w9?6x96w9?6x96w9?6x96w9;wx9݈w9;w`wx9݈w9;w`wxTTTRRRRRR?R?RSSSSSSSSSSSS?S?SSST9݈w9ww9݈w9ww9݈w97w96w97w96w97w96w97w96w9 w9 w9p? w9?? w9 w9? w9 w9w9w9?w9?w9?w9?> <?w9?8><w9.< 0 p~w9.? c~w9./>O~w9.~?w9.?~?w9.????w9-??w9-???w9-??w9-?? w9.???w9.??w9.??yw9.??qw9.??~3w9.???~#?w9.???|?w9.???|?w9.???|w9.???|w9.????~?w9.<>`w9/>?|?w9w9*? w9)? w9)? w9( w9) w9( w9(8 w9' w9( w9' w9)? w96w97w96w97w96w97w96w97w96w97w9 w9?w9?w9??w9?w9 w9 ?w9 ?w9A ?w9A w9 w9 w9?w9(??w9(??<w9(?<?w9(?>?y?w9(??>?w9(????w9(????~w9&?? ??~w9'????~?w9'?????w9'?????w9'?8????w9'?????w9(????w9(?? ?w9(??x?~~w9(???~w9(??~w9(???w9(;w????w9(3??w9(w9(<>??w9  ??w96w97w96w97w96w97w96w97w96w97w96w97w96w97w96w97w96w97w96w97w96w97w9݈w9ww9݈w9ww9݈wUUTyTeTeTeTeTe?? Te? Te Te Te Te Te??? Te?0 Te?8 x? Tj?~?<? Tj??>| Tj? ?>|?? Tj| ~?? Tj |?? Ta ?? Ta? Ta Ta Ta Ta/? Ta? Ta? Sa? Sa?|A Sa??|A Sa?~ÿ Sa??~;~ Sa<~ Sa| S?hÏ8 S?h?? S?h'Sh'Sh'Si'Si'Si'Si'Si'Si'Si'Si'SiSiSi?Si?Si?Si Si S?i T?i T?i T?i Ti?Ti??? Ti??? Ti Tj?>? Tj0?>s3? Tjp?~ ?7p? Tj?| >'p? Tj  |N? Tj ??|^ Tj?x?> Tj?> Tj?|Ti??|Tj?Ti?TiTpwi? Si?w Spqi?|w? S ixg?? Spwh_|?Si??S|h???Sh??Sw?wh'Rh'Rwqh'Rh'Rswg'Rh'Rg'Rg'Rw?wg'Qg'Qwqg'Qg'Qswf'Qg'Qf'Qf'Qw?wf'Pf'Pwqf'Pf'Pswe'Pf'Pe'Pe'Pw?we'Oe'Owqe'Oe'Oswd'Oe'Od'Od'Ow?wd'Nd'Nw qd'N d'Ns wc'N d'N c'N c'Nw? wc'M c'Mw qc'M c'Ms wb'M c'M b'M b'M? wb'M b'Lw qb'L wa'Lb'La'La'Lwa'La'K;qa'Ka'Kw`'Ka'K`'K`'Kw`'K?`'J;q`'J`'Jw_'J`'J_'J_'Jw_'J?_'I;q_'I_'Iw^'I_'I^'I^'Iw^'I?^'H;q^'H^'Hw]'H^'H]'H]'Hw]'H?]'G;q]'G]'Gw\'G]'Gÿ\'G\'G;w\'F?\'F8q\'F\'Fw['F\'FÏ['F['F;w['E['E8q['E['EwZ'E['EÏZ'EZ'E;wZ'DZ'D8qZ'DZ'DwY'DZ'DÏY'DY'D;wY'CY'C8qY'CY'CwX'CY'CX'CX'C:wX'BX'B8?qX'B?X'BwW'BX'BÎW'B&~?W'B&;?pwW'A'~<>` ~;wv'A'8`G ?qݖ'A'??;wv'A'???wݖ'A'??;wv'A(Ï??~?7'A(??~ݟ?7'A(;?~7'@)???7'@)8??7'@)???7'@)???7'@)??;?7'@*Ï??7'@*??>~?'@*;?~~ '?+?~? '?+8?~ '?+?? ?'?+?x??w?'?+?;???'?,Ï?>x???'?,??????'?;???'> ??'>8!?'>!?'>?>'>!@'8??8?'>!;@?(0<<0'>Ï!?`?( `~?>?  p?'>"??(/??/?~ ?'>;!?(???'=!?(???'=8"LJ(???'="?(???'=+(???'=+;?(???'=Ï,?(???'=-?(???'=;,?(???'<,??(????'<8-?(???'<-?(???'<-?(????'<-;?~?(???????'<Ï. ?~(?????'</ ~?(?????'<;. (?~??';. ?(?>8??';8/ )>?'; ?)??8';? ? ';? ;?$';Ï? ?c$';??$';;?$':??$':8 ?$': ???$': <<$':  p??;?$':Ï ~ ???$': ??#':; ?7'9 ??7'98 ?7'9 ??7'9; ?7'9 ?;97'99 ? ?6'9 ? 8?6'9; ? ?6':? ?À 8? ': ? ? ': ?;8? ': ?>` ': ???8? ': >': ?':; ';? Ï?'; 8 ';; ?';/ ';/8 ?2Ϟ|}p';/:> p??';/9?? ?x?`?<< x? ';;/9?8@?~?` '<?.Ï9?? σ^? '<.9????| '<.;9?????| '<-:???|1<-89????|2<-:???|1<-9????|2<;-:??~|1=?,Ï9???~|2=,:??~||1=,;9???~|2=+:??~|1=+89???|2=+:????|1=+9????|2=;+:??|1>?Ï9?????}|2> :߃??x;|1> ;9? o????|2> :?`???? ??<1> 89?p?0? 2>??72>;71??Ï?72?71?;?72?71? 8?72?+??71?+<?< ??72?+;? >8?71@*??Ï?72@)?71@*?;?72@*?71@)8?72@)71@)~?72@);~71A(?~?72A'~71A(~?72A(w1A'??2A'?w?1A'????2A';??s1B&????2B&??1B&??2B&?7??1B&p???2Bw?1B ??2B; s >?? 1C? ? ? 2C  ?? 1C ? p?`?>8? 2C w? ???? 1C ? ??? 2C w ??? 1C ? ??? 2C; s ??? 1D? ? ??? 2D ???1D? ???2Dw? 8???1D? ???2Dw ???1D? ??? 2D;s ??? 1E?? ????? 2E ????? 1E? ???? 2E w? ?}>? 1E ? ;;? 2Ew 3?? 1E? >? 2E; s <p? 1F? ?   2F 71F ?72F w?71F ??72F w71F ?72F8?s71G?72G71G???72G??w?71G?;wv2G?wݖ1G?;wv2G8sݖ1G;wv2H;HHÏw?HHwH?H8?sH?I;??I?IÏw?IIwII8?sIJ;JJÏw?JJwJJ8sJK;KKÏw?KKwKK8sKL;LLßw?L L wL Lq sL Mw M M w?M Mw wM Mq sM Mw N N w?N Nw wN Nq sN NwO Ow?OOwwOOqsOOwPPw?PPwwPPqsPPwQQw?QQwwQQqsQQwRRw?RRwwRRqsRRwSSw?SSwwSSqsSSwGTTw?TTwTTsTT?T ?T??T?T??T??T??T?T?T?T?T?pT??`T?T?T? T?T??T?T?T?T?T?T?R ?R ?R ?R ?R R ?R ?R ?RRxRRRSSSSSSSS?S?SSSSSSSTTwK;wnݛwKwK;wnݛwKwK?GK?GK?GK?GK?GK??GK??GK??GK ?? |K?  0? ?K  ? ?K  ? ?K  ? ?K? ?? ?K ?? ?K ? ?K ? ?K ? ?K ? ?K ? ?K |?<%8????>K|pp???|???K|`0`x?< ?<>?<????K|?@?X? >8~??8~>??p????K|?^????~????K|???????????K|????????K|??~?????K|??~???? ??K|??~?????K|?~|?????|??K|~|??????x??K|~|??????x??K|?~|???????x??K|?~|?????x??K|??????K|>??????K|~~?????Ko??~?????Ko???~?????Ko?????????}K|????????;~K|?@??K|???>??K|?pp?8K?? 3K*'?K*'?K*'?K*'K*'K*'K*'?K*'K*(K*(K*(KKKKKKKKKKK#K"?K"?K"? ?K" K  K  K  K  K  K  K  K B~?}}??ϟ?>K m?p??p ?>?~ K mx|?<~ <|?x`? ?p K m?~??|?`G8>?p? K m???????? π????? K m??????????? K m???????? K m???? K $?D???? K $?C ?? K $?C???? K $?C?? K $pÃ?pC???Ã K m??>?? K m???~ ?? K m??x????? K m?????? K m?~???? K m??~???? K m???~????? K m?????? K mw??w???~ K m<~?g?>?g??p???? K m|?0|0|??  K lxx? `p|K| K*DK*DK*DK*DK*DK)DK)DK*D?K*?JK*KKKKKKKKKK;wnݛwKwK;wnݛwKwwK;wnݛwKTTTTyTe?TeTeTeTe TeTe?Te?Te??Te??Te? Te?|?Ǐ?`? Tj`>  Tj~<x Tj~>| Tj~0~|?? Tj2?? Ta'??? Ta/? TaO? Ta_? Ta_? Ta?? Ta Ta? Ta Ta?? Ta|? Ra|; Ra ; Ra~w Rax/? Ra Rhq Rh? Rh(Rh(R?h(Rh(Ri(Ri(Ri(Ri(RiRiRiRiRi Ri Si Si Si Si Si?Si?SiSi?x>?S?i<>S?i`??>6`S?i ??~6S?i ??|&Si?L Si??\ Si?<Si?<Sj?xSjxSjSj?Sj?Sj<?Sj~|9?Sj~;>Sj7~Sj'~Sj???SjSj?Sj(Sj(Sj(Sk(Sj(Sj(Swwj(Rj(Rwqj(Rj(Rrwi(Rj(Ri(Ri(Rw?wi(Qi(Qwqi(Qi(Qswh(Qi(Qh(Qh(Qw?wh(Ph(Pwqh(Ph(Pswg(Ph(Pg(Pg(Pw?wg(Og(Owqg(Og(Oswf(Og(Of(Of(Ow?wf(Nf(Nwqf(Nf(Nswe(Nf(Ne(Ne(Nw?we(Me(Mwqe(Me(Mswd(M e(M d(M d(M? wd(M d(Lw qd(L d(L wc(L d(L c(L c(L wc(L c(K; qc(K c(K c(K b(K b(K wb(K? b(J;qb(Jb(Jwa(Jb(Ja(Ja(Jwa(J?a(I;qa(Ia(Iw`(Ia(I`(I`(I w`(I?? `(H; q`(H `(H w_(H `(H  _(H  _(H ? w_(H ?? _(G; q_(G_(Gw^(G x?>_(G ?^(G ^(G w^(G? ^(F; q^(F ?^(F w](F ^(F ](F ](F ?w](F? ?](E; ?q](E ](E ?w\(E ?](E \(E \(E w\(E? \(D; ?>q\(D ?\(D w[(D\(D[(D[(Dw[(D?[(C;q[(C[(CwZ(C[(CZ(CZ(CwZ(C?Z(B;qZ(BZ(BwY(BZ(BY(BY(BwY(B?Y(A;qY(A?Y(A?wX(A?Y(AX(AX(AwX(A?X(@;qX(@X(@ wW(@ X(@'?~??W(@'?p>?W(@'?`ǃ|<wW(@'??`G8>>W(?(;??qW(?(????W(?)???wV(?(???W(?)???ݔ(?)???󇻚wv(?)??wݔ(?)???󇻚wv(>;$??qݔ(>$??8(>$???w7(>???8(>??~???7(>???ݟ??8(>???7(>???8(=;??7(=?x??`~~?(=??8~?~?(=?;8?<(=?p?<?<(= ?< ?<(=)~?<(=?)~ ??~?(<;*??~?(<* ???~?(<*??~?(<*; ??~?(<+?g??~?(<+g %?>??(<+/%~8(<?+ %ρǃ~ 0(;;, ?? (;, ? ?? (;,?? ?? (;,;? ???? ???? (;- ????? ?~?~? (;- ?? ??? ?~~? (;- ?>??? ?~~? (;?- ?>? ?? ?>?? (:;. <?? ? (9 ? ??~?< ?? (9 ? ?; ?  (9 ? ???  (9 ? ? ? (9 ? ?0  ? (9???8(8;#???7(8#?ǃ<< 7(8   p?? 7(8 ? ~ ??8 7(8  ? 7(8 ? ? 7(8 ?? ??7(8 ?? ?ÿ8(8 ?? ??7 (8 ? ?;8 (8 ? ?7 (8 |? ?88 (88 |? ?7 (8 y? ?839; 9?? ?739 ;? ?Ï839Ï 3? ?739  ?;839 ? ???739 ?} >88398 ?; " 39   #? 3:;   !? 3: ?8Ï "? 3:Ï " 3:/; #3:. "?3:.8#?3:8."?3:-#?3;;-"?3;.Ï#?3;Ï-+>??>???3;-;,8?8??3;,,0ǃǃ0<x??< 3;,8-  p?#p?~|??3;8,-/??~ ??????3;+-??????3<;+-??????3<,Ï-???????3<Ï+-???????3<+;-???????3<*-??????3<*8-??????3<8*-??????3<)-???>???3=;)-???~???3=!Ï-??????????3=Ï-???|??????3=;-??????3=-?????3=8-?????3=8.??>??3=.??~???3>;.??`p ???3>.3>Ï.8?3> 3>? 83>8?w73><83?;s73??83?Ï??73??83???w?73????83?8??w73?83@;sݔ3@󇻚wv3@Ï?ݔ3@󇻚wv3@?w?ݔ3@?@8??w@?A;??sA?AÏ?xxxA?xAw?A?A8>?wAB;sB BÏBBw?BB8wBC;sCCÏCCw?CC8wCD;sDDÏDDw?D |?D8x? wDx? E;x? sEx? EÏEE?EE9wEF;}sF?>Fp|<wF ???F ???F ?F ?wF ?F; qG?G?wGGGG?wGG;σqH?߃HwHH?H<H??wH<|?H;qI?IwIIIIwII;qJ?JwJJJJwJJ;qK? K wK K K K wK K; qL L wL L L L wL Lw qM M? wM M M MswMMwqMNw?wNNNNswNNwqNOw?wOOOOswOOwqOPw?wPPPPswPPwqPQw?wQQQQswQQwqQRw?wRRxRRp7RRp1RSp7SSS?S?S ?S?S??S?S?S??S??S??S??S???S?S?S?S?S?S?~S??S?S?>S?w9?~w9w9w97w97w97w97w97w97w97w97w97w97w97w97w97w97w97w97w97w97w97w97w97w9# w9# w9" w9" w9# w9# w9# w9# w9# w9# w9# w9# w9+?|?w9,pA~w9-`??pw9-`G88?p?w9-????w9-?????w9-???w9-??w9-?w9-?w9-?w9-?w9-?Ãw9-?w9-?w9-?w9-?w9-??w9-??w9-??w9-w9-xx???~w9-?w9-x??@8w9-p?pw9 ??w97w97w97w97w97w97w97w97w97w97w97w97w97w97w97w97w97w97w97w9݉w9㒻ww9݉w9㒻ww9݉w5Table_ATable_ATable_DN /_ Noticetouser: (Thiscommentitemwillnotprintorshowupatallinfinalprintout.)  Togetintothetable,pressthedownorrightarrow.UsetheTABkeyormousetomovewithinthetable.(InatableTABmovesyouforwardinthetable,SHIFTTABmovesyoubackwardsinthetable.HOMEthenTABorCTRLTABwillgiveatabwithinthetable.) Savethefileas0000thefirstfourlettersinyourfirstname,pp-theideapagesheetnumber  (01,02,10,etc),andii-theideanumberonthatpage. Forexample:ifnameiswilliam,idea xx numberhasbeenlistedasI5.20,thenthefilenamewouldbeWILL05.20andtheideanumberzzzwouldbe05.20thoughoutthestudy(untilthevaluestudyteramassignsanewnumberinreport).Youcanusesearch,replacetochangetheprojectnameBigCreekRoad/CAPFH195-1(1)/HuntingtonLakeRoadtotheactualprojectnameandzzztotheideanumberspecification.Pleasedonotremovetemplateformatingfromtopsofpages.Table_Bhp psc 700 series printerT(,,,,T(0Table_CTable_ATable_Da /_ Noticetouser: (Thiscommentitemwillnotprintorshowupatallinfinalprintout.)  Togetintothetable,pressthedownorrightarrow.UsetheTABkeyormousetomovewithinthetable.(InatableTABmovesyouforwardinthetable,SHIFTTABmovesyoubackwardsinthetable.HOMEthenTABorCTRLTABwillgiveatabwithinthetable.) Savethefileas0000thefirstfourlettersinyourfirstname,pp-theideapagesheetnumber  (01,02,10,etc),andii-theideanumberonthatpage. Forexample:ifnameiswilliam,idea xx numberhasbeenlistedasI5.20,thenthefilenamewouldbeWILL05.20andtheideanumberzzzwouldbe05.20thoughoutthestudy(untilthevaluestudyteramassignsanewnumberinreport).Youcanusesearch,replacetochangetheprojectnameBigCreekRoad/CAPFH195-1(1)/HuntingtonLakeRoadtotheactualprojectnameandzzztotheideanumberspecification.Pleasedonotremovetemplateformatingfromtopsofpages.Table_BTable_CTable_Aq /_ Noticetouser: (Thiscommentitemwillnotprintorshowupatallinfinalprintout.)  Togetintothetable,pressthedownorrightarrow.UsetheTABkeyormousetomovewithinthetable.(InatableTABmovesyouforwardinthetable,SHIFTTABmovesyoubackwardsinthetable.HOMEthenTABorCTRLTABwillgiveatabwithinthetable.) Savethefileas0000thefirstfourlettersinyourfirstname,pp-theideapagesheetnumber  (01,02,10,etc),andii-theideanumberonthatpage. Forexample:ifnameiswilliam,idea xx numberhasbeenlistedasI5.20,thenthefilenamewouldbeWILL05.20andtheideanumberzzzwouldbe05.20thoughoutthestudy(untilthevaluestudyteramassignsanewnumberinreport).Youcanusesearch,replacetochangetheprojectnameBigCreekRoad/CAPFH195-1(1)/HuntingtonLakeRoadtotheactualprojectnameandzzztotheideanumberspecification.Pleasedonotremovetemplateformatingfromtopsofpages.Table_BTable_CTable_A =T!   _TRX3'X3' Letter3' Letter3'THH]IX@` 0Pp @ `"#X]8 XXdd8BZXBX  G~*>ddd Xdd Xdd X$$,Xdd ,dd +    p)F<,(`~0* `X9*E**nx j+p                                                                                                           _                               _                                                                 _ 2(#-)6 2 ,$,$l,$l,$  B` V` BZValueStudy#BZ` B` V# $d7 @1DRAFTREPORT 8   (PresentationReport)@@7A>') HxdE HA  $;  PROJECT: B@ ?BZ  _ >  UNACCOMPANIED K ? ENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)IIFORTDETRICK,MD #BZ ?B@l# B @@7A>') HxdEHA E BO BZDATE:October25,2002 G LO  BO#LZ LO#LNLZ  #BNLN##BZBN6#BO BZ#BZ BO#LZBZV  #BZLZ#LZBZLocationofStudy: $ Q #BZLZS#LZBZParkInnandSuitesofRockville,MD %!R (301)8815200LX XLZ N&"S   #LZXLX (#LNLZ#BNLN#LNBN  $ $X@$#LZLN##BZLZ#LZBZFacilitatedby: '#U J.SamuelMartin,PE,CVS,CVTAssistedby: >)~%W CarolM.Landau,AssistanttoCVSSAMI(SystematicAnalyticMethodsandInnovations) *'Y  POBox1115,Evergreen,CO80437 (303)6746900 #BZLZc#;1/+'Z0 ,$,$ ;G~ G8(6(dXXd8 G  ZFX@` 0Pp @ `"$Z   *rNO ddXdd Xdd >$$r,x`` +  7DDJD6"  KK7B !BZVALUESTUDYTEAMACKNOWLEDGMENTOFACTIVITY 0p TEAMANDCONSULTANTS#BZ!B ح# S>DDD@,l" K K DDJD6 S0   "" TheaimofusingtheValueMethodistoachievethebestworthforthecost(value)fortheproject.Itisonlywiththefullteameffort,asshownbyallinvolved,thatthisgoalcanbeachieved.Thisstudyrepresentstheproductofsuchaneffort.3)'  0  >DDD 3`FX@` 0Pp @ `"X@`*_RS ddx`` xNO$$_,xHH +  7DDJD6"   KK7B !BZGENERALDISCUSSIONOFTHEVALUEMETHOD ; {  PROCESS,ITSPURPOSE,ANDTHISVALUESTUDY#BZ!B # S>DDD@,w " K K DDJD6 STheValueMethodisahighlyeffectivedecisionmakingprocess.Itconsistsofseriesofproceduresthatoccurapreplannedsequence.Itwasoriginallydevelopedin1943byLarryMiles.Ingeneral,itisa systematicandorganizedprocesstocreativelydevelopalternativesthatsecureessentialfunctionsatthegreatestworthasopposedtotheirlifecyclecost(highestvalue).Ithasmanyapplicationsbutismostoftenusedasamanagementandproblemsolvingtool.Ajobplanisusedthroughoutthevaluestudyactivity.Inbrief,thecomponentfeaturesfromaprocess,program,project,oractivityareexaminedtodeterminepertinentfunctions,governingcriteria,andassociatedcosts.Then,throughcreativitytechniques,resultingideaanalysis,anddevelopmentoftheremainingbestideas;alternativemethodsthatfullymeetnecessaryrequirementsatalowercost,orwithanincreaseinthelongtermvalues,areproposedforadoptionbythepartiesresponsiblefortheproject.Thisreportistheresultofa"formal"ValueStudyTeameffort.Aformalvaluestudyteamiscomprisedofpeoplewiththedesiredexpertiseandindependence.Theyhaveanunderstandingoftheneedsoftheorganizationtheyrepresent,andcantakeanopenandindependentviewoftheprojectbeingstudied.Ideally,theyhavenotbeennotablyinvolvedintheprojectpriortothevaluestudy.UsingtheValueMethodappliedtothecurrentcollecteddata,thestudyteamtakesa"freshlook"attheprojecttocreatealternativesthatfulfilltheclientneedsatthegreatestrecognizedattainablevalue.TheValueMethodhasmanycommonnames.Thesemainlyrelatetothehistoricalfeatures,thetimingofitsapplication,ortypeofprocess,program,project,oractivitystudied.Itisoftenreferredtoas:ValueAnalysis(VA),ValueManagement(_VM_),ValueEngineering(VE),andValuePlanning(VP).Theapplicationoftheprocesshasbeenhighlysuccessfulfornearly60yearsforbothprivateandgovernmentalentities.Asaresult,theFederalgovernmenthasmandateditsuseinallFederallyfundedoperations.ThisvaluestudyreportdemonstratestherequiredsubstancethatqualityValueMethodprocedureswereusedthroughoutthisvaluestudy,asstipulatedunderthemandatedgovernmentalValueProgramoversightauthoritiesandtherecommendationsoftheValueMethodprofession.3)'%!& 0   >DDD 3  &"& HZ@@` 0Pp @ `"X@Z8 XXd(d8W  X|   Vm  Vm(0 @    EXECUTIVESUMMARY#<$<$\$. @$@$#1Vm((݌ T Ќ  Vm  Vm)0 @    VALUESTUDYTEAMMEMBERS#<$<$\$.$@$@$#3Vm))݌  Ќ  Vm  Vmc*0 @    DESCRIPTIONOFPRESENTACTIVITYPLAN#<$<$\$.  0@$@$#4Vmc**݌ t   Ќ  Vm  Vm7+0 @    COSTMODEL#<$<$\$.@$@$#5Vm7+S+݌  4  Ќ  PROPOSALNO.1DeleteBalconies<$<$\$.\\+6   Vm  VmC,0 @    PROPOSALNO.2ReplaceFacadeAccentStrips.#<$<$\$.8@$@$#8VmC,_,݌ $T  Ќ  PROPOSALNO.3ReplaceBathtubsWithShowers##[$.ll810  Vm  Vm-0 @    PROPOSALNO.4DirectBuryPrimaryCables.###[$.pp6@$@$#12Vm--݌ Dt Ќ  PROPOSALNO.5RemoveFiberOptics##[$.||.14  Vm  Vm.0 @    PROPOSALNO.6ReduceRefrigeratorSize.###[$.4@$@$#16Vm..݌ d Ќ  PROPOSALNO.7LowerRoof##[$.  %18 $ ADDITIONALCONCEPTSFORFURTHERSTUDY##[$.120  Vm  Vm/00 @    DISPOSITIONOFIDEAS###[$. @$@$#20Vm/0K0݌ D Ќ  Vm  Vm00 @    SUPPORTINGDOCUMENTS###[$. @$@$#23Vm01݌  Ќ  Vm  Vm10 @     @ GLOSSARYOFPERTINENTSTANDARDVALUEMETHODTERMS###[$.A@$@$#24Vm11݌ 4d! Ќ  Vm  Vm20 @     @ GLOSSARYOFOTHERTERMSANDACRONYMS###[$.4@$@$#26Vm22݌ # Ќ  Vm  Vm30 @     @ =GENERALDESCRIPTION==ORALPRESENTATION/INITIALBRIEFINGMEETINGATTENDANCELIST=###[$. #@$@$#>27>>43>Vm33݌ T % Ќ  ? @   ?Vm  Vm40 @    @ @ @SPECIALCRITERIASUMMARY###[$.(@$@$#A27AA49AVm44݌ ! ' Ќ  Vm  Vm50 @    B @ BFUNCTIONANALYSISSYSTEMTECHNIQUE(FAST)DIAGRAM###[$.A@$@$#C28CC49CVm55݌ t#!) Ќ  Vm  Vm60 @    D @ DEXPLANATIONOFALTERNATIVEEVALUATION###[$.5@$@$#E30EE51EVm67݌ %4#+ Ќ  !  !70 @ 0@$@$ @   FGeneralDiscussion###[$.` ` "$$#51!78݌ %#, Ќ  Vm  Vm80 @    DESCRIPTIONOFSELECTIONPROCESS###[$.,@$@$#51Vm88݌ \'%. Ќ  F (W<!78݌ %#,$$ Ќ  _xd X@_ -k9 X"'(&*.e016389q>x*_ ddxHH xRS$$_, +  7DDJD6"  /K7B !BZ  EXECUTIVESUMMARY ;#BZ!B ،;# W>DDD," K / DDJD6 @W PROJECT: 󀀀 UNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2 NDDD;# @ >DD kN General : +[ ThevaluestudyteamconsistedofexpertisefromArchitectural,Mechanical,Electrical,Civil,andCostEstimatingprofessions.TheteamhadtheirfirstgroupmeetingforthevaluestudyonWednesday,October23,2002andconcludedfullformalteameffortsonFriday,October25,2002.Apresentationtomanagementofthe_FHWA_,NFS,WAGroup,andothers,ofthevaluestudyresultstookplaceattheconclusionofthe4daystudyonFriday,August9,2002.Afterthecompletionofthecommentperiod,aFinalReportwillbeissuedalongwiththeteamsfinalrecommendations.Achargetotheteamofmeetingthedesigncriteriaandprojectfunctionswhilebringingthetotalprojectcostswithinanacceptablebudgetlimitwasmade. SummaryofProposals : /  Thevaluestudyteammadeatotalof seven majoralternativeproposals(Thesearealternativemethodsthatwere   developedduringthevaluestudytothepointthattheywerecompleteenoughfordecisionmakingandcomprehensivepresentation"alternativerecommendation").ThroughtraditionalValueMethodprocedures,theteamevaluatedtheactivitywithregardtothenumerousactionsandavailableresources(time,money,equipment,etc.).Inadditiontotheconceptsestablishedbeforethevaluestudy,thestudyteamgeneratedadditionalconcepts.Inaccordancewiththerelativeranking,thestudyteamdevelopedandevaluated_ppp_Ԁspecificproposalsthatweredeterminedtohaveahighenoughpotentialtomeettheneedsfortheplannedactivity.The totalestimatedinitialexpendituresavings oftheevaluationscompleted  duringthevaluestudy,ifallindependentmonetarysavingsproposalsareaccepted,areestimatedatabout $237,000 .Thisshouldallowtheprojecttobebuiltwithinthespecified9.7millionlimitspecifiedintheteam k charge.Theprocessalsogeneratedseveral valueadded featurestotheconcepts.(Valueaddedfeaturesaredefinedas  attributesthatthestudyteambelieveswillimprovethefinalproductinnonmonetaryorhardtoquantifyways,e.g.,time,quality,andsafety.Averybriefdescriptionandanestimateoftheminimumpotentialvalueoftheproposalsare:8  ProposalNo.1.Removeextendedbalconyonbothsides. Projectedsavingareexpectedtobe {" $6,800ormore. <"<" 0  ProposalNo.2.Removeallbrickaccentsandreplacewithprecastconcrete. Projectedsavingare !?$ expectedtobe$41,000. ## 0  ProposalNo.3.Replaceallbathroomtubswithshowers. Projectedsavingareexpectedtobe$48,000."&## 0  ProposalNo.4.Directburyprimaryelectricalcables. Projectedsavingareexpectedtobe$81,000.o# '## 0  ProposalNo.5.Removeallfiberoptics. Projectedsavingareexpectedtobe$6,000.;$k!(## 0  ProposalNo.6.Replaceallfullsizerefrigeratorswith3/4size. Projectedsavingareexpectedtobe %7") $35,000. ## 0  ProposalNo.7. Lowerthecentralroofandmakeituniformthroughoutthebuilding. Projected &#+ savingsareexpectedtobe$19,000. ## 0   ##  N>DD;#,G)2 k DDD  N J>DDD7#?.o+4  >DD oJ_ SummaryofAdditionalConceptsforFurtherStudy .    Five additionalconceptsforfurtherstudywerealsorecommended.Theseareconceptsthat,duetotime , constraints,thelackofapparentlargesignificantsavingsorvalueaddedduringinitialideaevaluations,complexityofconcept,orscopeoftheconcept(ascomparedtothestudyscope),makefurtherinvestigationbythestudyteam,withintheirlimitedtimeconstraints,inadvisable.Theyarerespectfullysubmittedforfurtherconsiderationanddevelopmenttoaddvaluefortheproject.Theywerenotdevelopedtothedetailofthepreviousalternativeproposalsbythestudyteam. AdditionalConcept#1. Replacethecurrentbrickfacadewithsplitface,withtheoptionofusing12'block.    AdditionalConcept#2. Uselargeraccenttilesthroughoutthebuilding. t   AdditionalConcept#3. Usenonmetalliccablingforsecondarydistributionthroughoutthebuilding. @   AdditionalConcept#4. Extendthetwoseparatebarrackstoshareacommonwall.    AdditionalConcept#5. ReplacethebrickfacadewithEIFS. K   <>DDD)#  0 o >DDD <.$"4  0  >DDD .  , HH8*__ dd 8%8%_, l< , L< , Ll +  0& H x0BBZVALUESTUDY#BZBS#B !BZ x PROJECT:#BZ!B S#BxdyBZ F<  " x   lxFUNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2 F< " x l  xF#BZyBxd:T#BLMBZ  VALUESTUDYTEAMMEMBERS [U#BZMBL9U# MDDJ68  T" x   KMNAME AD>J6,! "DDJ6 ATITLE/DISCIPLINE AD>JD6,! "D>J6 ACONTACTINFORMATION N>D?, " K  D>JD6 CNF88Vu  $Cc1P !o#$ X@_ -k9 X"'(&*.e016389q>AnthonyV._Colicchio_ԀJr.,PE ;>>,! C>D C;F88Vu  $Cc1P !o#$88Vu $CP !Valuestudyteamleader,Facilitator,CivilEngineer,CostEstimator ?>>D,!C>> C?F88Vu  $Cc1P !o#$88Vu $CP !10S.HowardSt.Baltimore,MD21203Phone:4109626723Fax:4109621850 N>D?'o'C  >>D CNShawnM.Crossfield,_EIT_ ;>>,!C>D C;MechanicalEngineer ?>>D,!C>> C?F88Vu  $Cc1P !o#$88Vu $CP !10S.HowardSt.Baltimore,MD21203Phone:4109623883Fax:4109623680 N>D?'wC  >>D CNPeteSingleton,_EIT_ ;>>,!OC>D C;ElectricalEngineer ?>>D,!OC>> C?10S.HowardSt.Baltimore,MD21203Phone:4109623902Fax:4109623680 N>D?'7#C  >>D CNJean_Swalley_,AIA ;>>,!W$C>D C;Architect ?>>D,!W%C>> C?10S.HowardSt.Baltimore,MD21203Phone:4109623880Fax:4109623680 P>DD?'?!+C  >>D CP =>>D,!",C>DD C= ?>>DD,!"-C>>D C?7-+".C   >>DD 7  ". 9H W* d d l<  L<  Ll _8%8%, ll +  ," 9 <,-#!u<" <  -BX XBZ*_ dd ll 8%8%_,X ll +  ," U <,#BZXBX `#B !BZ  DESCRIPTIONOFPRESENTACTIVITYPLAN a#BZ!B ضa# JDDJD65X" <  vlcJPROJECT:UNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2 W>DDD,Q lc v DDJD6 LWThedesignproposalpresentedtothevaluestudyteamistoconstructthreebarracksontheFt.Detrickinstallation.Eachbarracksistoholdatotalof48unenlistedpersonnel.Everytwobarracksroomswillshareacommonbathroomandsmallkitchenette.TheKitchenettewillcontainarefrigeratorandmicrowave.Thebarrackswillcontainacommonlaundryroom.Thecurrentestimateforthesefacilitiesis$9.7million.Theprimaryobjectiveofthevaluestudyteamistofindwaystomeettheprojectobjectivesasclosetomeetingthebudgetasfeasible. N>DDD;#@   L  >DD ;LHN3)'l3  LH ;  >DDD 3*_ ddX ll X 8%8%_,g `` +   2DDJD6 D  lc2 2DDJD6 D  lc2 BO BZCOSTMODELANDESTIMATEINFORMATION#BZ BOf#  I>DDD6'w " lc DDJD6 LHI R>DDD?'w " lc DDJD6 LHR^DDp L T\ d!#&l(*-t/1$4|68,;=?4B88Vu $CP !Theteamscostmodelwasbasedontheconceptualestimatesprovidedbythedesign(orprocess)teamforthepreferredconceptthatwaspresentedtothestudyteam.Itwasusedtofocusonfeatureswiththegreatestpotentialforsavings,andtohighlightpotentialinstancesofvaluemismatch.(Areasthathavelowworthincomparisontotheirprojectedcost.)Toensurereliabilityandapplicability,allunitpriceswerereviewedbybothestimatorsandthestudyteam.Estimator(s)wereindependentfromboththestudyteamordesignandprocessteam.Valuestudyproposalandoriginalconceptestimatesareofthesamegenerallevelofdevelopment.Itshouldberecognizedthatunitcostsandestimatesmayvaryasfinalactivitiesarepursuedandrefined.3)'' LH   >DDD 3   V    u     $    C    c  -* Ї   V *eddg `` g 8%8%e,g `` +  2DDJD6  lc2 BO BZCOSTMODELANDESTIMATEINFORMATION#BZ BOCm# R>DDD?'T" lc DDJD6 LHR^DDp L T\ d!#&l(*-t/1$4|68,;=?4B88Vu $CP !Theteamscostmodelwasbasedontheconceptualestimatesprovidedbythedesign(orprocess)teamforthepreferredconceptthatwaspresentedtothestudyteam.Itwasusedtofocusonfeatureswiththegreatestpotentialforsavings,andtohighlightpotentialinstancesofvaluemismatch.(Areasthathavelowworthincomparisontotheirprojectedcost.)Toensurereliabilityandapplicability,allunitpriceswerereviewedbybothestimatorsandthestudyteam.Estimator(s)wereindependentfromboththestudyteamordesignandprocessteam.Valuestudyproposalandoriginalconceptestimatesareofthesamegenerallevelofdevelopment.Itshouldberecognizedthatunitcostsandestimatesmayvaryasfinalactivitiesarepursuedandrefined.3)'  LH   >DDD 3 9.+, ! d !""X9X*_ ddg `` g 8%8%_,syI@,[ II@,YI@, Iy@+  0&   jC0LZBZL !LZ  EVALUATIONFORPROPOSALNO.1#B !!L ^s##BZ!B }s# GDD8  C  j  0CG`C88Xx  (Hh8X !x#DXpX`PROJECT: q CDD0!bCDD CCWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WUNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2LZBZ V>DG/bC 0  DD CV qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W COMPONENT: q 9>,!:C>D C9 WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WBuil#dwithinbudget#$dingEnclosure$ ;>>,!:C> C; qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W FUNCTION: q ?>D,!:C>> C? WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WSaveCost%s% ]>DD6H,:C   >D C] q  WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WALTERNATIVEDESCRIPTION Y>DDF*j C   >DD6 CY PROPOSALNO.1 .DELETEBALCONIES     [DD6F*~ C  >DD 0C[  WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W BENEFITS q HD>D63$ v C DD6 CH q  WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WDISADVANTAGES q U>DF* vC  0 D>D6 CU #BZLZϛu#LZBZReductionincastinplaceconcretequantity  N #BZLZϥ|#LZBZReductioninconstructiontime#BZLZ-}#LZBZ  -  #BZLZύ}#LZBZImprovevisualimpact#BZLZ}#LZBZ d   F>>D3$C C>D CF#BZLZ@~#LZBZRequiresredesigneffort  N #BZLZ~#LZBZRevisionresultsinslightlydifferentappearancethan  -  surroundingbarracksbuildings [DDD6F*M C  >>D 0C[ qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W IDENTIFIEDRISKS: q U>DDDB*; C 0 DDD6 CU WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W#BZLZV#LZBZ ZGqNonenoted.:0. C 0  >DDD :* d dsyI@s[ II@[ YI@ Iy@ 8%8%,s|L@,}L|@,LL@,G\L@,^ \|@+  0&    C0<B.88@ HPX "88BL !LZ ZG<  WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88XW COSTCOMPARISONFORPROPOSALNO.1#LZ!L Ń#L !LZ  GDD8 G C    0CG WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W#LZ!L ش#PROJECT: q CDD0![CDD CC qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W#BZLZϢ#UNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2LZBZ `DD6K/[C 0  DD 0C`  WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W ORIGINALCONCEPT ZG HD>D63$SC DD6 CH ZG  WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WVALUESTUDYCONCEPT ZG UDDF*SC  0 D>D6 0CU ZGWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W#BZLZ#LZBZ2'widebalconieslocatedateachexteriorcorridoratthe K centralstair q FD>D3$kCDD CF qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W#BZLZlj#LZBZConsiderdeletingthebalconies,whichdonotserve K  itsintendedpurpose. W>DDD6B*3"C 0 D>D CW  WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W COSTITEMS ZG H>D63$ #C >DDD6 CH  WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WNONRECURRING D>>DD6/$ $C >D6 CD  WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WLIFECYCLE VDDC' %C  0 >>DD6 CV ZGWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WORIGINALCONCEPT q =3$&CDD C=WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀ$46,800 3>D 'C C3 qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀ$ q V>DDC'(C >D CV qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀVALUECONCEPT() q @>3$)C>DD C@ qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀ$40,000 B>>D/$*C> CBWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀ$ q V>DDC'+C  >>D CV qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀSAVINGS q @>3$[,C>DD C@ qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀ$6,800 B>>D/$[-C> CBWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀ$ q V>DDC'[.C  >>D CV qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀNUMBEROFUNITS(X) q _>R$3/C>DD  ?1C?_ qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀ1 q a>>DNC30C  ?1 ?> Ca qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀ q V>DDC'31C  >>D CV qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀTOTALSAVINGS q @>3$c 2C>DD C@ qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀ$6,800 q B>>D/$c 3C> CB qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀ$ q V>DDC'c 4C  >>D CV qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀIMPLEMENTATIONCOSTS() q @>3$;5C>DD C@ qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀ$ q B>>D/$;6C> CB qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀ$ q O>DDD6:';7C  >>D CO q  WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W NETSAVINGS ZG H>D63$8C >DDD6 CH ZGWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀ$6,800 D>>DD6/$9C>D6 CDWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀ$ ZG MC':C 0 >>DD6 CM<B.88@ HPX "88B ZG<WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88XWLYLZNotes: - +!G<C  +   X    x     (    H    h         #LZLYr#LYLZԹ* d ds|L@s}L|@}LL@G\L@G^ \|@^ 8%8%,[S@,S@+  0& n= C0<B.88@ HPX "88B<  WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88XW#LZLYﱡ#L !LZ DESCRIPTIONVALUESTUDYPROPOSALNO.1 #LZ!L ѣ# q-  IDD>8 ?C    0CI qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WPROJECT: q}b ?D>D,! -@CDD> C?WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W#BZLZ3#UNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2LZBZ [DDDH, -AC 0  D>D C[ q}bWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W Background :Thebarrackshaveexteriorcorridorswithbalconyextensionsatthecentralstairways.Theextensions %"C protrude2'fromthefaceofthebuilding.Atthisdepth,theextensionsaresufficientforaccommodatingpersonnelstandingoutsideofthecirculationpath.Itisntsufficientforaccommodatingseating,gatheringingroups,etc. Proposal :Sincethebalconyextensionsareineffectiveasausableoutdoorlivingspace,anddonotaddsignificant I%"G value,considerthefollowing:C o $#CZF88dXx  (Hh8X !x#88Z0   Deletethe2'widebalconyextensionsatthecentralstaironboththefrontandrearbuildingfacadesonthetwoisolatedbarracks. ;$;$ 0   Thisproposalwillnotonlyreducetheexteriorcorridorarea,butwillsimplifytheconcreteformwork.Thiswillreducethetotalcostforcastinplaceconcrete. ;$;$ 0    D:8*m(N;$;$C  DDD D*r dd[S@[S@8%8%r,X @+  ," X C,<H.4 <DL!T$88dH<  WCl  <\| ,Ll !#%XWL !LZ IMPLEMENTATIONOFPROPOSALNO.1  HDDD5 C   0CH WCl  <\| ,Ll !#%W#LZ!L G#PROJECT: q#BZLZ#UNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2LZBZ YDDD6D,x C 0  DDD 0CY qWCl  <\| ,Ll !#%W CRITICALITEMSTOCONSIDERINIMPLEMENTATIONOFPROPOSAL: q R>DD?'tC 0 DDD6 CR qWCl  <\| ,Ll !#%WThisproposalrequiresreassessmentofthestructuralconditionsfortheexteriorcorridors. M>DD:'LC  >DD CM R>DD?'$ C  >DD CR R>DD?'  C  >DD CR T>DD6?' | C  >DD CTWCl  <\| ,Ll !#%W IDENTIFIEDPOTENTIALPROBLEMSANDMETHODSTOOVERCOME: q R>DD?' T C  >DD6 CR qWCl  <\| ,Ll !#%WNonenoted. R>DD?' , C  >DD CRWCl  <\| ,Ll !#%W q T>DD6?'\  C  >DD CT qWCl  <\| ,Ll !#%W RECOMMENDEDPROCEDURES:(WHODOESWHAT) q R>DD?'4 C  >DD6 CR qWCl  <\| ,Ll !#%WThestructuraldesignerfirstassessestheproposedchangetoensurecontinuedstructuralintegrity. R>DD?'  C  >DD CRWCl  <\| ,Ll !#%WThearchitecturaldesignerrevisestheexteriorcorridorconfigurationintheplansandelevations. N>DDD;' C  >DD rCNWCl  <\| ,Ll !#%W<20dC 0 r >DDD < jl M jl HX]IX@` 0Pp @ `"#]   X    x     (    -G  W   X    *_OP ddX @X 8$8$_,l< , << ,L< , <l +  0&  <0L !LZ&&EVALUATIONFORPROPOSALNO.2 GDD8 <" <   +lG#LZ!L M#PROJECT: CDD0!DD C#BZLZ#UNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2LZBZ V>DG/ l + DD LVCOMPONENT: 9>,!(>D 9BuildingEnclosure ;>>,!(> ;FUNCTION: ?>D,!(>> ?ReduceCosts ]JDD6H,( L  >D F]ALTERNATIVEDESCRIPTION ^>DDK/O"  F JDD6 YL^  PROPOSALNO.2. о#BZLZϡ#ZBZԀ REPLACEFACADEACCENTSTRIPS #BZZ #ZBZ  C     E+ 4 <DL!X@E#BZZφ# `DD6K/ O  L Y >DD +l`BENEFITS HD>D63$[  "DD6 HDISADVANTAGES ZJDK/[  " l + D>D6 ZBX XBZX XXBX Ԁ#ZXX L#Reducebuildingexteriorcosts    #BZZk#ZBZImprovevisualimpact#BZZ #ZBZX XZ     ]I,l  <\| ,Ll !!%X]#ZXX ##BZZ`# FJ>D3$v JD FInconsistentwithsurroundingbarracks    Introducingadditionaltrade/material WDDD6B&    J>D +lWIDENTIFIEDRISKS: ^>DDDK/  l + DDD6 ;LH^ZBZNoapparentrisks#BZZ#6,*. LH ;  >DDD 6*RS d dl<  <<  L<  <l OP8$8$,l< ,2<l ,<< ,GL< ,^ Ll +  0& > <0B !BZ  COSTCOMPARISONFORPROPOSALNO.2  GDD8 :z" <   +lG#BZ!B ؿ#PROJECT: CDD0!:DD CUNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2 W>DD6B&: l + DD ;LHWORIGINALCONCEPT H>>DD63$&f">DD6 HVALUESTUDYCONCEPT Z>DK/&f" LH ; >>DD6 YLZ$176,000 J  =>>D*R>D =$135,000 WJDDD6B&J L Y >>D vHWCOSTITEMS HJD63$y"JDDD6 HNONRECURRING DJ>DD6/$y "JD6 DLIFECYCLE [DDH,y!" H v J>DD6 <[ЀORIGINALCONCEPT 4*$"DD 4Ѐ$176,000 !>D # !Ѐ$ R>DD?#$ < >D LRЀVALUECONCEPT() @>3$1%>DD @Ѐ$135,000 9>>D&1&> 9Ѐ$ R>DD?#1' L  >>D LRЀSAVINGS @>3$](>DD @Ѐ$41,000 9>>D&])> 9Ѐ$ R>DD?#]* L  >>D LRЀNUMBEROFUNITS(X) _>R$I+>DD  ?1?_Ѐ1 w>>Dd:I,  ?1 ?>  ?1?wЀ1 q>DD^BI-  ?1 L  ?>>D LqЀTOTALSAVINGS @>3$u .>DD @Ѐ$41,000 9>>D&u /> 9Ѐ$ R>DD?#u 0 L  >>D LRЀIMPLEMENTATIONCOSTS() @>3$!1>DD @Ѐ$ 9>>D&!2> 9Ѐ$ TJDDD6?#!3 L  >>D vHTNETSAVINGS HJD63$#H4"JDDD6 HЀ$41,000 DJ>DD6/$#H5JD6 DЀ$ I?,#H6 H v J>DD6 <IBYBZNotes:'T$ 7 <   '#BZBY#HXBYBZ  &"9 *VW d dl< 2<l 2<< GL< G^ Ll ^ RS8%8%,\l< ,<l +  0&  <0#BZBY#B !BZ  DESCRIPTIONVALUESTUDYPROPOSALNO.2 L#BZ!B -# IDDJ8 <" <   vlcIPROJECT: 6DJD#!DDJ 6UNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2 RDD?# lc v DJD <R Background : + Thebarracksfloorlevelsareaccentedonthefacadebyalineofvertical soldierbricks.Additionalvisualaccentsareprovidedbyabrickarchabovetheentrancetothecentralstairwell.Theaccentsprovideaestheticinterestandvisuallybreakupthewideexpanseofbrickfacade.Thistypeofmasonryworkislaborintensive.Thesameeffectscanbeachievedbymorecosteffectivematerials.  Proposal : g  Formoreeffectivefacadeaccents,considerthefollowing:Deletevertical soldierbrickaccentstripsateachbarrackfloorlevelandabovetheentrancetothecentralstairwell.Replacewithprecastconcreteunits.Thisproposalwillreducethetotalcostofthebuildingenclosure. U>DDDB&s <  DD ;LHU6,* LH ;  >DDD 6BYBZ*rXY dd\l< \<l VW8%8%r,X ll +  ,"  <,#BZBYw#B !BZ  IMPLEMENTATIONOFPROPOSALNO.2  ?DDD,+" <  ,l?#BZ!B |# PROJECT: 󀀀UNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2 PDDD6;# l , DDD +lPCRITICALITEMSTOCONSIDERINIMPLEMENTATIONOFPROPOSAL: I>DD6,; l + DDD6 LI  K+ 4 <DL!,Xl! KZBZThisrequirescarefulassessmentofthedifferentialthermalexpansionofthebrickandaccentmaterialsandtheresulting 'g appropriateconnectionmethods.#BZZϭ# I>DD6'/ L >DD LI E>DD2#[ L  >DD LE E>DD2#G L  >DD LE P>DD6;#s L  >DD LP IDENTIFIEDPOTENTIALPROBLEMSANDMETHODSTOOVERCOME: N>DD;,  L  >DD6 LNSeeabove. E>DD2#!   L  >DD LE E>DD2#"7! L  >DD LE E>DD2##$c " L  >DD LE P>DD6;#O%!# L  >DD LP RECOMMENDEDPROCEDURES:(WHODOESWHAT) N>DD;,{&"$ L  >DD6 LNThearchitecturaldesignerrevisestheexteriorfacadeaccentmaterialandensuresappropriateconnectionsareused. E>DDD2#'#% L  >DD ;LHE3)'(%& LH ;  >DDD 3LZBZ  )#&& ` jl HX]IX@` 0Pp @ `"#X]*_bc ddX ll X XY8$8$_,l< , << ,L< , <l +  0&  <0L !LZEVALUATIONFORPROPOSALNO.3 GDD8 X" <   +lG#LZ!L ر#PROJECT: CDD0!DD C#BZLZ#UNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2LZBZ V>DG/ l + DD  LVCOMPONENT: 9>,!D>D 9Mechanical ;>>,!D> ;FUNCTION: ?>D,!D >> ?ReduceCosts ]JDD6H,D  L   >D F]ALTERNATIVEDESCRIPTION ^>DDK/O "  F JDD6 YL^  PROPOSALNO.3 ReplaceBathtubsWithShowers  C    `DD6K/ k L Y >DD +l`BENEFITS HD>D63$[ "DD6 HDISADVANTAGES ZJDK/[ " l + D>D6 ZReducesmechanicalcosts  Increasesspace R Provideseasiermaintenance v  =J>D*>JD =Nobubblebaths  Possiblylessattractivetosoldier#BZLZ#LZBZ R Minorredesigneffortrequired#BZLZ#LZBZ v  WDDD6B&>   J>D +lWIDENTIFIEDRISKS: ^JDDK/. l + DDD6 F^Nonenoted U>DDDB&  F JDD ;LHU6,* LH ; >DDD 6*de d dl<  <<  L<  <l bc8$8$,l< ,2<l ,<< ,GL< ,^ Ll +  0& -  <0L !LZ  COSTCOMPARISONFORPROPOSALNO.3 f GDD8  i " <   +lG#LZ!L G#PROJECT: CDD0!)"DD C#BZLZT#UNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2LZBZ W>DD6B&)"  l + DD ;LHWORIGINALCONCEPT H>>DD63$U#!">DD6 HVALUESTUDYCONCEPT U>DF/U#"" LH ; >>DD6 LU$78,000forbathtubs y%$  =>>D*A&%>D =$30,000forshowers y%'  RJDDD6=!u'* L >>D vHRCOSTITEMS HJD63$8)+"JDDD6 HNONRECURRING DJ>DD6/$8),"JD6 DLIFECYCLE [DDH,8)-" H v J>DD6 <[ЀORIGINALCONCEPT 4*$( *.DD 4Ѐ$78,000 !>D ( */ !Ѐ$ R>DD?#( *0 < >D LRЀVALUECONCEPT() @>3$T!+1>DD @Ѐ$30,000 9>>D&T!+2> 9Ѐ$ R>DD?#T!+3 L  >>D LRЀSAVINGS @>3$",4>DD @Ѐ$48,000 9>>D&",5> 9Ѐ$ R>DD?#",6 L  >>D LRЀNUMBEROFUNITS(X) _>R$#.7>DD  ?1?_Ѐ1 w>>Dd:#.8  ?1 ?>  ?1?wЀ1 q>DD^B#.9  ?1 L  ?>>D LqЀTOTALSAVINGS @>3$$4/:>DD @Ѐ$48,000 9>>D&$4/;> 9Ѐ$ R>DD?#$4/< L  >>D LRЀIMPLEMENTATIONCOSTS() @>3$&`0=>DD @Ѐ$ 9>>D&&`0>> 9Ѐ$ TJDDD6?#&`0? L  >>D vHTNETSAVINGS HJD63$k'1@"JDDD6 HЀ$48,000 DJ>DD6/$k'1AJD6 DЀ$ I?,k'1B H v J>DD6 <ILYLZNotes:Assumeallotherbiditemsareunchanged (3C ';,6H <   '#LZLY#HX#BZLZϯ#BYBZLYBY  .8J *hi d dl< 2<l 2<< GL< G^ Ll ^ de8%8%,\l< ,<l +  0&  <0#LZLY#L !LZ  DESCRIPTIONVALUESTUDYPROPOSALNO.3 #LZ!L ؍# IDDJ8 <" <   vlcIPROJECT: 6DJD#!DDJ 6#BZLZ#UNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2LZBZ RDD?# lc v DJD <R Background : + Currentlybathtubsarebeinginstalledinallofthebarracksrooms. Proposal :  O  Consideringtheenduserforthebarracks,itisrecommendedthatthebathtubsineachroombereplacedwithshowers.Theshowerswouldbeasignificantsavingswithoutalossofvalue.Thecurrentsanitaryandwaterlinescouldbeusedwithaminormodification,whileopeningupmorebathroomspaceforotherfeatures. U>DDDB&;  <  DD ;LHU6,*'g  LH ;  >DDD 6#BZLZ#LZBZ  *xdd\l< \<l hi8%8%x,X ll +  ,"  <,L !LZ  IMPLEMENTATIONOFPROPOSALNO.3   ?DDD,C" <  ,l?#LZ!L # PROJECT: 󀀀UNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2 PDDD6;# l , DDD +lPCRITICALITEMSTOCONSIDERINIMPLEMENTATIONOFPROPOSAL: I>DD6,S l + DDD6 LI  E+ 4 <DL!X@E#BZLZ#ZBZDesignersmustconsidermoistureprotectionintherevisedchange.#BZZ8#Ԁ I>DD6'? L >DD LI E>DD2#k L  >DD LE E>DD2# L  >DD LE P>DD6;# L  >DD LP IDENTIFIEDPOTENTIALPROBLEMSANDMETHODSTOOVERCOME: I>DD6,/ L  >DD6 LIThesanitaryandwaterlineswillrequireaslightredesign.Theshowermayrequireafloordrainaspercode. @>DD-[ L >DD L@ E>DD2#G L  >DD LE E>DD2#s L  >DD LE P>DD6;#  L  >DD LP RECOMMENDEDPROCEDURES:(WHODOESWHAT) N>DD;,!  L  >DD6 LNInspectcodeforinformationregardingshowerfloordrains. E>DDD2#"7 L  >DD ;LHE3)'#$c  LH ;  >DDD 3  3%s!  *_ ddX ll X 8%8%_,l< , << ,L< , <l +  0&  <0B !BZEVALUATIONFORPROPOSALNO.4 GDD8 <" <   +lG#BZ!B 7 #PROJECT: CDD0!DD CUNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2LZBZ V>DG/ l + DD  LVCOMPONENT: 9>,!(>D 9Electrical ;>>,!(> ;FUNCTION: ?>D,!(>> ?CostSavings ]JDD6H,( L   >D F]ALTERNATIVEDESCRIPTION ^>DDK/O"  F JDD6 YL^  PROPOSALNO.4 .0 DIRECTBURYOFPRIMARYCABLE  {   T$ T$ Directburyprimarycablesinlieuofconcretecasing. `DD6K/G   L Y >DD +l`BENEFITS HD>D63$  "DD6 HDISADVANTAGES ZJDK/  " l + D>D6 ZReduceselectricalcosts.  :  Decreasecableinstallationtime. =J>D*  JD =Unprotectedline. WDDD6B& :    J>D +lWIDENTIFIEDRISKS: ^>DDDK/N  l + DDD6 ;LH^Potentialserviceoutageiflineisdamaged.6,*:z  LH ;  >DDD 6* d dl<  <<  L<  <l 8%8%,l< ,<l ,X<< ,GL< ,^ Ll +  0& J  <0L !LZ  COSTCOMPARISONFORPROPOSALNO.4  GDD8  " <   +lG#LZ!L y#PROJECT: CDD0!FDD C#BZLZY #UNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2LZBZ W>DD6B&F l + DD ;LHWORIGINALCONCEPT H>>DD63$r">DD6 HVALUESTUDYCONCEPT Z>DK/r" LH ; >>DD6 YLZEncasedcables   =>>D*>D =Directburycables WJDDD6B& L Y >>D vHWCOSTITEMS HJD63$="JDDD6 HNONRECURRING DJ>DD6/$="JD6 DLIFECYCLE [DDH,=" H v J>DD6 <[ЀORIGINALCONCEPT 4*$IDD 4Ѐ$101,250 !>D I !Ѐ$ R>DD?#I < >D LRЀVALUECONCEPT() @>3$u >DD @Ѐ$20,250 9>>D&u!> 9Ѐ$ R>DD?#u" L  >>D LRЀSAVINGS @>3$#>DD @Ѐ$81,000 9>>D&$> 9Ѐ$ R>DD?#% L  >>D LRЀTOTALSAVINGS @>3$ &>DD @Ѐ$81,000#BZLZ#LZBZ 9>>D& '> 9Ѐ$ R>DD?# ( L  >>D LRЀIMPLEMENTATIONCOSTS() @>3$9)>DD @Ѐ$ 9>>D&9*> 9Ѐ$ TJDDD6?#9+ L  >>D vHTNETSAVINGS HJD63$`,"JDDD6 HЀ$81,000 DJ>DD6/$`-JD6 DЀ$ I?,`. H v J>DD6 <I' / <   'LYLZ  !/ * d dl< <l X<< XGL< G^ Ll ^ 8%8%,\l< ,<l +  0&  <0#LZLY#L !LZ  DESCRIPTIONVALUESTUDYPROPOSALNO.4 #LZ!L b# IDDJ8 <" <   vlcIPROJECT: 6DJD#!DDJ 6#BZLZ&#UNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2LZBZ R>DDD?# lc v DJD ;LHR Background : ; Currentlytheprimarypowerfortheinstallationisbeingfedbyoverheadlinesthattransitionundergroundinconcreteencased_ductbanks_Ԁtosupplypowertoeachfacility. Proposal :  '  Werecommend_transitioning_Ԁtheprimaryfeedersbydirectburialmethodsinsteadofconcreteencasement.#BZLZ#LZBZԀDirect {  buryingtheprimarycablewillbeamajorcostsavingsanditwillstillprovidethesamefunction.6,*C  LH ;  >DDD 6LYLZ*r dd\l< \<l 8%8%r,X ll +  ," S  <,#LZLY!#L !LZ  IMPLEMENTATIONOFPROPOSALNO.4 # ?DDD, " <  ,l?#LZ!L "# PROJECT: 󀀀#BZLZ !#UNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2LZBZ PDDD6;#O  l , DDD +lPCRITICALITEMSTOCONSIDERINIMPLEMENTATIONOFPROPOSAL: N>DD;, l + DDD6 LNTherewillbeasmallerstandoffdistancewithotherundergroundutilities. E>DD2#  L  >DD LE E>DD2#7 L  >DD LE E>DD2##c L  >DD LE P>DD6;#O L  >DD LP IDENTIFIEDPOTENTIALPROBLEMSANDMETHODSTOOVERCOME: N>DD;,{ L  >DD6 LNTheprimarylinewillnothavethesameamountofprotectionagainsttrenchingasitwouldinaconcreteencasedductbank.Thiswouldincreasethechancesofthelinebeinghit,andcausinganoutage. E>DD2#o L  >DD LE E>DD2# L  >DD LE E>DD2# L  >DD LE P>DD6;#3 L  >DD LP RECOMMENDEDPROCEDURES:(WHODOESWHAT) N>DD;,_ L  >DD6 LNFollowtheguidelinesintheNationalElectricCode,NEPA,etc.fordirectburyingprimarycablesandtheirstandoffdistanceswithotherutilities. E>DD2#!S L  >DD LE E>DD2#?" L  >DD LE E>DDD2#k# L  >DD ;LHE3)'$  LH ;  >DDD 3#BZLZ$#LZBZ  %!  ?+ 4 <DL!X?#BZLZ+#X  *_ ddX ll X 8%8%_,yI@,= II@,YI@, Iy@+  0& L C0< @8  @H <  WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#XWB !BZ EVALUATIONFORPROPOSALNO.5  GDD8 C    0CG WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W#BZ!B q-#PROJECT: q CDD0!pCDD CC qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WUNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2LZBZ V>DG/pC 0  DD CVWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WCOMPONENT: 9>,!HC>D C9WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WElectrical ;>>,!HC> C;WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WFUNCTION: ?>D,!HC>> C?WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WReduceCost ]>DD6H,H C   >D C]  WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W ALTERNATIVEDESCRIPTION q Y>DDF*  C   >DD6 CY qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W PROPOSALNO.5 DELETEFIBEROPTICS D    q [DD6F*  C  >DD 0C[ q  WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W BENEFITS q HD>D63$ C DD6 CH q  WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WDISADVANTAGES q U>DF* C  0 D>D6 CU#BZLZϟ/# qC o $$oCNocosts  $  C o $$oCWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W q F>>D3$p C>D CF qC o $$oCZF88dXx  (Hh8X !x#88ZWillhavetopullfiberopticcablefromanothersourceif  $  neededinthefuture.LZBZ p  C o $$oC]C88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88d] q [DDD6F*8 C  >>D 0C[kB.88@ HPX "88B qkWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88XW IDENTIFIEDRISKS: q U>DDDB* C 0 DDD6 CUWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W ZGq#BZLZ>9#LZBZNonenoted. qZG:0.s C 0  >DDD :LX XLZ q* d dyI@= II@= YI@ Iy@ 8%8%,-|L@,L|@,LL@,G\L@,^ \|@+  0& k  C0<#LZXLX <#<  WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WL !LZ COSTCOMPARISONFORPROPOSALNO.5  GDD8 #C    0CGWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W#LZ!L ?#PROJECT: q CDD0!CDD CC qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W#BZLZf<#UNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2LZBZ `DD6K/C 0  DD 0C`  WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W ORIGINALCONCEPT ZG HD>D63$ C DD6 CH ZG  WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WVALUESTUDYCONCEPT ZG UDDF* C  0 D>D6 0CU#BZLZQA# ZGWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W$6,000 G!  q FD>D3$"CDD CF qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W$0 G$  q W>DDD6B*%C 0 D>D CW q  WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W COSTITEMS ZG H>D63$k&C >DDD6 CH  WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WNONRECURRING D>>DD6/$k'C >D6 CD  WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WLIFECYCLE VDDC'k(C  0 >>DD6 CV ZGWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀORIGINALCONCEPT q =3$c)CDD C= qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀ$6,000 q 3>D c*C C3 qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀ$ q V>DDC'c+C >D CV qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀVALUECONCEPT() q @>3$;,C>DD C@ qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀ$0 q B>>D/$;-C> CB qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀ$ q V>DDC';.C  >>D CV qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀSAVINGS q @>3$/C>DD C@ qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀ$6,000 q B>>D/$0C> CB qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀ$ q V>DDC'1C  >>D CV qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀNUMBEROFUNITS(X) q _>R$g2C>DD  ?1C?_ qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀ1 q >>DmCg3C  ?1 ?>  ?1C? qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀ1 q u>DDbFg4C  ?1  ?>>D Cu qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀTOTALSAVINGS q @>3$?5C>DD C@ qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀ$6,000 q B>>D/$?6C> CB qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀ$ qLZBZ V>DDC'?7C  >>D CV qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀIMPLEMENTATIONCOSTS() q @>3$8C>DD C@ qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀ$ q B>>D/$9C> CB qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀ$ q T>DDD6?':C  >>D CT q  WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W NETSAVINGS ZG H>D63$s;C >DDD6 CH ZGWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀ$6,000 ZG D>>DD6/$s<C>D6 CD ZGWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WӀ$ ZG MC's=C 0 >>DD6 CM LYLZ+!k>C  + ZG   @ X#LZLYgZ##BZLZT#B !BZL !!B * d d-|L@-L|@LL@G\L@G^ \|@^ 8%8%,[S@,S@+  0&  C0<B.88@ HPX "88B#LZ!L @[#LYLZ<  WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88XW#LZLY ]#L !LZ DESCRIPTIONVALUESTUDYPROPOSALNO.5#LZ!L ]# q IDD>8 <C    0CI qWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88WPROJECT: q}b ?D>D,!,CDD> C? q}bWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W#BZLZ_[#UNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2LZBZ [DDH,,C 0  D>D C[WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W Background : H Currentlyfiberopticsarebeingprovidedforthebarracksfacilities,andwillterminateinsidethebuildings.Coppercablealsobeprovidedandwillbeusedasthemainsourceforcommunications. Proposal :  l  Werecommendthatfiberopticsnotbeprovidedforthisfacility.Thechancesofafiberopticssystembeingusedastheprimarysourceofcommunicationsarerare.Deletingthefiberopticswillresultinsignificantcostsaving. q U>DDDB*L  C DD CUWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88W ZGq:0.$ C 0  >DDD :*r dd[S@[S@8%8%r,X @+  ,"   C,<B.88@ HPX "88B ZG<  WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88XWL !LZ IMPLEMENTATIONOFPROPOSALNO.5  HDDD5X C   0CHkB.88@ HPX "88B kWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88XW#LZ!L آe#PROJECT: 󀀀#BZLZ`#UNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2LZBZ q YDDD6D,/ C 0  DDD 0CYkB.88@ HPX "88B qkWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88XW CRITICALITEMSTOCONSIDERINIMPLEMENTATIONOFPROPOSAL: q R>DD?'C 0 DDD6 CR R>DD?'nC  >DD CRTheelectricaldesignerverifieswiththecustomerthatfiberopticswillnotbeneededinthenearfuture. R>DD?'FC  >DD CRKB.88@ HPX "88B qKWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88XW q T>DD6?'iC  >DD CTKB.88@ HPX "88B qKWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88XW IDENTIFIEDPOTENTIALPROBLEMSANDMETHODSTOOVERCOME: q R>DD?'C  >DD6 CR R>DD?'dC  >DD CRNonenoted. R>DD?'<C  >DD CRKB.88@ HPX "88B qKWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88XW q T>DD6?'_C  >DD CTKB.88@ HPX "88B qKWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88XW RECOMMENDEDPROCEDURES:(WHODOESWHAT) q R>DD?' C  >DD6 CRKB.88@ HPX "88B qKWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88XW qDonotprovidefiberopticsforthisfacility. R>DD?'!"C  >DD CRKB.88@ HPX "88B qKWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88XW qUsecoppercableastheprimarysourceforcommunications. N>DDD;'D$C  >DD CNKB.88@ HPX "88B qKWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88XW ZG7-+g&C 0 >DDD 7#BZLZϓg# jl HX]IX@` 0Pp @ `"#88]  {() p jcIX@` 0Pp @ `"#X@c*_rs ddX @X 8$8$_,l< , << ,L< , <l +  0&  <0B !BZEVALUATIONFORPROPOSALNO.6 GDD8 X" <   +lG#BZ!B v#PROJECT: CDD0!DD CUNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2 V>DG/ l + DD  LVCOMPONENT: 9>,!D>D 9Mechanical ;>>,!D> ;FUNCTION: ?>D,!D >> ?ReduceCosts ]JDD6H,D  L   >D F]ALTERNATIVEDESCRIPTION ^>DDK/ "  F JDD6 YL^  PROPOSALNO.6 . yԀREDUCEREFRIGERATORSIZE N    `DD6K/a  L Y >DD +l`BENEFITS HD>D63$ E"DD6 HDISADVANTAGES ZJDK/ E" l + D>D6 ZReduceequipmentcosts # Increasecounterspace 2  =J>D*AJD =Lessrefrigeratedstoragespace # Lessattractivetosoldiers WDDD6B&2   J>D +lWIDENTIFIEDRISKS: ^>DDDK/% l + DDD6 ;LH^Nonenoted6,*Q LH ;  >DDD 6*tu d dl<  <<  L<  <l rs8$8$,l< ,2<l ,<< ,GL< ,^ Ll +  0& a <0B !BZ  COSTCOMPARISONFORPROPOSALNO.6 ~ GDD8 " <   +lG#BZ!B ~#PROJECT: CDD0!]!DD CUNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2 W>DD6B&]! l + DD ;LHWORIGINALCONCEPT H>>DD63$"">DD6 HVALUESTUDYCONCEPT Z>DK/"" LH ; >>DD6 YLZ$64,000 \$   =>>D*k&!>D =$29,000. WJDDD6B&\$# L Y >>D vHWCOSTITEMS HJD63$j'$"JDDD6 HNONRECURRING DJ>DD6/$j'%"JD6 DLIFECYCLE [DDH,j'&" H v J>DD6 <[ЀORIGINALCONCEPT 4*$('DD 4Ѐ$64,000 !>D (( !Ѐ$ R>DD?#() < >D LRЀVALUECONCEPT() @>3$J)*>DD @Ѐ$29,000 9>>D&J)+> 9Ѐ$ R>DD?#J), L  >>D LRЀSAVINGS @>3$v +->DD @Ѐ$35,000 9>>D&v +.> 9Ѐ$ R>DD?#v +/ L  >>D LRЀNUMBEROFUNITS(X) _>R$!:,0>DD  ?1?_Ѐ1 w>>Dd:!:,1  ?1 ?>  ?1?wЀ1 q>DD^B!:,2  ?1 L  ?>>D LqЀTOTALSAVINGS @>3$"f-3>DD @Ѐ$35,000 9>>D&"f-4> 9Ѐ$ R>DD?#"f-5 L  >>D LRЀIMPLEMENTATIONCOSTS() @>3$#.6>DD @Ѐ$ 9>>D&#.7> 9Ѐ$ TJDDD6?##.8 L  >>D vHTNETSAVINGS HJD63$a%/9"JDDD6 HЀ$35,000 DJ>DD6/$a%/:JD6 DЀ$ I?,a%/; H v J>DD6 <IBYBZNotes:'&E1< <   '#BZBY#BYBZ  ,\7A *xy d dl< 2<l 2<< GL< G^ Ll ^ tu8$8$,\l< ,<l +  0&  <0#BZBY#B !BZ  DESCRIPTIONVALUESTUDYPROPOSALNO.6 #BZ!B # IDDJ8 <" <   vlcIPROJECT: 6DJD#!DDJ 6UNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2 RDD?# lc v DJD <R Background : r Eachbarracksmodulehasafullsizerefrigeratorprovidedaspartofasharedkitchenette. Proposal : 6   Replacethefullsizerefrigeratorwitha3/4sizerefrigerator.Thiswillnotonlyresultinacostsavings,butwillallowmorecounterand/orcabinetspacetobeprovided.Consideringthatthekitchenettehaslimitedfoodpreparationequipment,andthesoldiersusuallyeatinthenearbydiningfacility,thefullsizerefrigeratorisunnecessary. U>DDDB&s  <  DD ;LHU6,*# LH ;  >DDD 6   X    x *xdd\l< \<l xy8$8$x,X @+  ," ` C,<H.88@ HPX "X@H ZG<  WC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88XWB !BZ IMPLEMENTATIONOFPROPOSALNO.6  HDDD5C   0CHkB.88@ HPX "88B kWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88XW#BZ!B #PROJECT: 󀀀UNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2LZBZ q YDDD6D,sC 0  DDD 0CYkB.88@ HPX "88B qkWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88XW CRITICALITEMSTOCONSIDERINIMPLEMENTATIONOFPROPOSAL: q R>DD?'VC 0 DDD6 CR R>DD?'.C  >DD CRNonenoted. R>DD?'C  >DD CRKB.88@ HPX "88B qKWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88XW q T>DD6?')C  >DD CTKB.88@ HPX "88B qKWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88XW IDENTIFIEDPOTENTIALPROBLEMSANDMETHODSTOOVERCOME: q R>DD?'LC  >DD6 CR R>DD?'$C  >DD CRNonenoted. R>DD?' C  >DD CRKB.88@ HPX "88B qKWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88XW q T>DD6?' "C  >DD CTKB.88@ HPX "88B qKWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88XW RECOMMENDEDPROCEDURES:(WHODOESWHAT) q R>DD?'!B$C  >DD6 CRKB.88@ HPX "88B qKWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88XW qThearchitecturaldesignershallreconfigurethekitchenettetousetheextraspacefromthisproposal. N>DDD;'"e&C  >DD CNKB.88@ HPX "88B qKWC88Xx  (Hh8X !x#88XW ZG7-+ $ (C 0 >DDD 7  %!( *_ d dX @X 8$8$_,l< , << ,L< , <l +  0&  <0L !LZEVALUATIONFORPROPOSALNO.7 GDD8 <" <   +lG#LZ!L C#PROJECT: CDD0!DD CUNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2 V>DG/ l + DD  LVCOMPONENT: 9>,!(>D 9BuildingEnclosure ;>>,!(> ;FUNCTION: ?>D,!(>> ?ReduceCosts ]JDD6H,( L   >D F]ALTERNATIVEDESCRIPTION ^>DDK/"  F JDD6 YL^  PROPOSALNO.7 .Lowercentralroofportion u N    `DD6K/a   L Y >DD +l`BENEFITS HD>D63$ ) "DD6 HDISADVANTAGES ZJDK/ ) " l + D>D6 ZReducescosts #   =J>D*2 JD =Inconsistentwithotherbarracks #  Reducestheareawithsufficientheadheight#BZLZܓ#LZBZ 2   WDDD6B&A    J>D +lWIDENTIFIEDRISKS: ^>DDDK/  l + DDD6 ;LH^NoneNoted6,*5 LH ;  >DDD 6* d dl<  <<  L<  <l 8$8$,l< ,2<l ,<< ,GL< ,^ Ll +  0& E <0L !LZ  COSTCOMPARISONFORPROPOSALNO.7  GDD8 " <   +lG#LZ!L v#PROJECT: CDD0!ADD CUNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2 W>DD6B&A l + DD ;LHWORIGINALCONCEPT H>>DD63$m">DD6 HVALUESTUDYCONCEPT Z>DK/m" LH ; >>DD6 YLZ$144,000 \  =>>D*k>D =$101,000 \   WJDDD6B&k! L Y >>D vHWCOSTITEMS HJD63$N""JDDD6 HNONRECURRING DJ>DD6/$N#"JD6 DLIFECYCLE [DDH,N$" H v J>DD6 <[ЀORIGINALCONCEPT 4*$%DD 4Ѐ$144,000 !>D & !Ѐ$0 R>DD?#' < >D LRЀVALUECONCEPT() @>3$J(>DD @Ѐ$101,000 9>>D&J)> 9Ѐ$0 R>DD?#J* L  >>D LRЀSAVINGS @>3$v +>DD @Ѐ$43,000 9>>D&v ,> 9Ѐ$0 R>DD?#v - L  >>D LRЀNUMBEROFUNITS(X) _>R$!.>DD  @2@_Ѐ2 X>>DE:!/  @2 @> XЀ R>DD?#!0 L  >>D LRЀTOTALSAVINGS @>3$"J1>DD @Ѐ$86,000 9>>D&"J2> 9Ѐ$0 R>DD?#"J3 L  >>D LRЀIMPLEMENTATIONCOSTS() @>3$#v 4>DD @Ѐ$6,000(Design) 9>>D&#v 5> 9Ѐ$0 TJDDD6?##v 6 L  >>D vHTNETSAVINGS HJD63$a%!7"JDDD6 HЀ$80,000 DJ>DD6/$a%!8JD6 DЀ$0 I?,a%!9 H v J>DD6 <ILYLZNotes:AddedCost_TBD_'&)#: <   '#LZLYﯳ#  y'#: *$3 d dl< 2<l 2<< GL< G^ Ll ^ 8$8$,\l< ,<l +  0&  <0L !LZ  DESCRIPTIONVALUESTUDYPROPOSALNO.7 #LZ!L ؃# IDDJ8 <" <   vlcIPROJECT: 6DJD#!DDJ 6UNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2#BZLZޥ#LZBZ R>DDD?# lc v DJD ;LHR Background :  #BZLZ#  ?+ 4 <DL!88?ZBZThethreeproposedbarrackshaveastandingseamroofwithahighmidsectiontoallowforadditionalincreasefloorattic   space.Thisincreaseatticspaceisforlockerroomstoragespace.Thishighatticroommidsectionrequiresahigherwallsection.Thishighwallsectioniscontrastbycomparingwallsections#1and#2onsheetA34.Theatticareaisservedbyonestairwellandhas48lockers.Theconcretefloorareaisaprecastconcretedeck.Therooflineofatypicalbarracksisattwoelevations/levels.#BZZ#LZBZ 9    Proposal : W  #BZLZU#?+ 4 <DL!X?ZBZItissuggestedthattherooflevelbedroppedtothelowerrooflevel/elevationorsectionNo.1.Thiswillreducethewall j  sectionNo.1.Thiswillinturnreducethewallsectionareaandmaketherooflineuniformandeasiertoconstruct.Inordertoregainthelossheadheight,thelockerarrangementwillhavetobereconfiguredtoamoreelongatedpattern.Theconcretedeckingfortheatticareawillbeutilizedforsupportingusageloadsratherthandeadspace.#BZZ#LZBZ > ?53M LH ;  >DDD ?*r45 dd\l< \<l $38$8$r,X ll +  ," ] <,L !LZ  IMPLEMENTATIONOFPROPOSALNO.7  ?DDD," <  ,l?#LZ!L |# PROJECT: 󀀀UNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2#BZLZF#LZBZ PDDD6;#Y l , DDD +lPCRITICALITEMSTOCONSIDERINIMPLEMENTATIONOFPROPOSAL: N>DD;,- l + DDD6 LN#BZLZϠ#]I,l  <\| ,Ll !!%X] qZGZBZAredesignwillberequiredforthetwobarrackbuildings.Thisredesignwillbeminimumandconsistoftheatticfloor Y plan.#BZZ3# qLZBZ E>DD2#! L  >DD LE#BZLZ#ZBZThelifesafetyissuewillhavetobeconsideredinthisproposal,sincethereisaincreasetraveldistancetothecenter M stairwell.Themainrooftrusssystemmaypossibilityhavetoberedesignedandreconfigured(10eachperbuilding).#BZZϣ#LZBZ E>DD2# L  >DD LE P>DD6;#A L  >DD LP IDENTIFIEDPOTENTIALPROBLEMSANDMETHODSTOOVERCOME: N>DD;,m L  >DD6 LN#BZLZ#  iI,l  <\| ,Ll !!%,Xl! i qZBZThisproposalwillhavetwoofthebarracksatdifferentheightsthantheotherbarracks.Sincethesetwobuildingsareat  differentlocationsfromtherestofthebarracksbuildings,thedifferentelevationsandrooflineswillnotbereadilynoticeable.Thebarracksbuildingsmayneedaslightincreaseintheroofslopetoallowadditionalheadroomwhichmay q#BZZ#K+ 4 <DL!,Xl! KZBZmakeupfordifferenceintheroofelevationsfromthetwosinglebuildingsandthemainbarracksbuilding.#BZZ#LZBZ N>DD;,! L  >DD LN#BZLZϨ#  ?+ 4 <DL!X?ZBZThisproposalmayrequirethesoldierpersonneltotravelaslightlylongerdistancetothelockerspace.Thistraveldistance 4" willbemadeupbyanincreasecentertravel(staging)area.#BZZσ#LZBZ N>DD;,"x  L  >DD LN P>DD6;#($ ! L  >DD LP RECOMMENDEDPROCEDURES:(WHODOESWHAT) N>DD;,T%!" L  >DD6 LN#BZLZϔ#]I,l  <\| ,Ll !!%X] qZBZRecommendthatthePMinformedtheuserastotheproposedchangetoseeifitinterfereswiththerefunctions.#BZZb# qLZBZ E>DD2#&"# L  >DD LE#BZLZ)#iI,l  <\| ,Ll !!%,Xl! i qZBZThedesignteamshouldmeetanddiscussthisproposalandincorporatethedesignchanges.#BZZ/# qLZBZ E>DDD2#'($$ L  >DD ;LHE3)'(T%% LH ; >DDD 3  )d&% #BZLZ#*_ ddX ll X 458$8$_,l< ,<< ,FL< ,Ll +  0&  <0 BBZ  ADDITIONALCONCEPTSFORFURTHERSTUDY  #BZB# < (ALISTINGOFITEMSWITHPOTENTIALFORCOSTOROTHERVALUEIMPROVEMENT) GDD8 <" <   +lG PROJECT: CDD0! DD CUNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2 WDDJ6B&  l + DD lcW@>> DESCRIPTION DD>J6/$ DDJ6 D @ "DESTIMATEOF X @ $DDOLLARS@ #DINVOLVED AD>JD6,!d D>J6 A@{{B' REMARKS W>DH,   lc  D>JD6 LW LZBZLX XLZSplitFace  _   Replacethebrickfacadewithsplitfaceblock#BX XXLX O##BZXBX n# 5>>&7 >D 5BX XBZ$145,000#BZXBX X# ?>>D,!_ ">> ?BX XBZThesplitfaceblockcanresultinreducedmaterialand _  laborcosts. @>D1#K  L  >>D L@ AccentTile     Uselargeraccenttile s  throughoutthebuilding 5>>&_ >D 5$2,700 6>>D#!  ">> 6Usingalargeraccenttileinthebuildingslowerscost,providesfasterinstallation,andeasiermaintenance. ;>D,s  L >>D L; Nonmetalliccable +   Usenonmetalliccable  forthesecondarydistributionthroughoutthebuilding 5>>&_>D 5$37,000 6>>D#!+ ">> 6Usingnonmetalliccableforsecondarydistributionisnotonlycheaper,buteasiertoinstall. ;>D, L >>D L; CombineBarracks +   Extendbothbarracksto ! shareacommonwall 5>>&">D 5Unknownbutmaybesignificant 6>>D#!%">> 6Extendthetwoseparatebarrackstomaximizethespace,savecostsandimproveforceprotection. ;>D,' L >>D L; EIFS S(  Replacethebrickfacade ?) withEIFS 5>>&+*>D 5$58,000 6>>D#!S+">> 6TheuseofEIFSinsteadofbrickprovidesforafasterandcheaperinstallation..$"?- L  >>D .* ddl< << FL< FLl 8$8$,El< , Ll +  0& /- <0B !XBX  VALUESTUDY 󀄀  DISPOSITIONOFIDEAS #BX X!B ؒ# F< k." <   <FPROJECT:LX XXBX LZXLX UNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2#BZLZk##BX XBZϊ# QDDJD6< / <   vlcQVALUESTUDYELEMENTSCONSIDEREDASPOTENTIALPROPOSALSANDTHEIRDISPOSITION V>DG/[1" lc v DDJD6  LV CONCEPT/IDEA ?>>D,!z!2">D ? DISPOSITION E>D6,z!3" L   >>D LE E "F4 DeleteBalconies  #2 5 Removethebalconyextensionsontheexteriorcorridors ->>D$!6>D -Selectedasbeinganeasyrevisionandhavingpotentialforreturn.DevelopedandpresentedasProposalNo.1. 9>D>(% ": L >>D L(9 I &Z#; ReplaceFacadeAccentStrips  'F$< Replacebrickfacadeaccentswithprecastconcretestrips. ->>>D(2%=>D> -Selectedasbeinganeasyrevisionandhavingpotentialforreturn.DevelopedandpresentedasProposalNo.2 7>D()&A L( >>>D L7 B +~'B ReplaceBathtubsWithShowers  +j(C Deletebathtubsandreplacewithshowers. ->>D,V)D>D -Selectedashavingpotentialforreturn.DevelopedandpresentedasProposalNo.3. 9>D>(,V)G L >>D L(9 G  L  DirectBuryPrimaryCable   8 Directburytheprimarycable. ->>>Ds $>D> -Selectedashavingpotentialforreturn.DevelopedandpresentedasProposalNo.4. 7>D(s $ L( >>>D L7 M   DeleteFiberOptics  p Deletethefiberopticsfromtheproject. ->>D\ >D -Selectedashavingpotentialforreturn.DevelopedandpresentedasProposalNo.5. 9>D>(\  L >>D L(9 Q   ReduceRefrigeratorSize   Reducetherefrigeratorfromfullto3/4size. ->>>D>D> -Selectedashavingpotentialforreturn.DevelopedandpresentedasProposalNo.6. >>D>- L( >>>D >L(> A 3  LowerRoof    Lowerthecentralroofportion. ->>>D  >D> -Selectedashavingpotentialforreturn.DevelopedandpresentedasProposalNo.7. J>D;#   L( > >>>D LJ K q"  LX XXBX SplitFace  ] Replacethebrickfacadewithsplitfaceblock#BX XXLX Z# ->>DI>D -PresentedinOtherConceptsforConsideration. >>D>-#] L  >>D L(> C J AccentTile Uselargeraccenttilethroughoutthebuilding ->>>Dq" >D> -PresentedinOtherConceptsforConsideration. 9>D>(6" L( >>>D L(9 D # Nonmetalliccable Usenonmetalliccableforthesecondarydistributionthroughout Z% thebuilding ->>>D F&>D> -PresentedinOtherConceptsforConsideration. 9>D>(n( L( >>>D L(9 L !) CombineBarracks Extendbothbarrackstoshareacommonwall ->>>D#~+>D> -PresentedinOtherConceptsforConsideration. G>D>6"- L( >>>D L(G F -%. PrecastPlanks  &/ Replacecastinplaceconcretefloor/ceilingassemblieswithprecastplankconstruction. ->>>D'1>D> -PresentedinOtherConceptsforConsideration. L>D>;#&3 L(  >>>D L(L N Q)4 PTAC  =*5 UsePackageThroughAirConditioningunits. ->>>D)+ 6>D> -PresentedinOtherConceptsforConsideration. L>D>;#=*8 L(  >>>D L(LLX XXBX  H  L WoodFrameConstruction   8  #BX XXLX #Usewoodframeconstructioninlieuofsteel. ->>>Ds $>D> -PresentedinOtherConceptsforConsideration. L>D>;# 8 L(  >>>D L(L 6>>>D# >D> 6.3)'  L(   >>>D 3       B` V` XBX  Supporting  Documents BX X` B` V  , 8*r"# ddEl< E Ll  $$r,X HH +  7DDJD6"  TW7B !XBX   GLOSSARYOFPERTINENTSTANDARDVALUEMETHOD $T TERMS #BX X!B a# W>DDD,`" TW  DDJD6 (4 WAnnualCosts .Theannualexpenditureoffundsorotherresourcestoensuretheproduct's 'W satisfactorycontinuedfunctioningduringitseconomiclife. AlternativeAnalysisMatrix .Aprocessusingtheresultsofthecriteriaweightingtodeterminethe 3 apparentrelativerankforvariousidentifiedalternatives. AlternativeValueIncrementComparison .Acomparisonprocedureusedtoevaluatethe   comparativeincrementalworthversusitsincrementalcostforaseriesofalternativesthatmeettheidentifiedessentialneedsrelativelyequally. Benefits,Disadvantages,andRiskAnalysis .Anassessmentidentifyingthebenefits,disadvantages,   andpossibleassociatedrisksrelatedtopursuingaparticularalternativetoitsfinalconclusion. BasicFunction .Themainfunction(s)thatmeetstheessentialneedsoftheprocess,procedure,or   activitythattheproductmustachieve. CertifiedValueSpecialist .Apersonwhohasbeencertifiedtohaveallthequalificationstoconduct, _  monitor,guide,andinstructpeopleinthepracticeoftheValueMethodprocessfromSAVEInternational. Component .Anidentifiedportionoftheprocess,procedure,oractivityunderstudy.Thesemaybe 'W aphysicalfeatureor"mission"typefeaturessuchasthestatedpurposesfortheactivity. CostModel .Aillustrativediagramthatshowstherelationshipofexpendituresastheyrelatetothe 3 functionsandcomponents. CriteriaWeighting .Aprocedureappliedtothegoverningcriteriatodeterminetherelativeweight  ofspecificcriteriaasitrelatestotheothercriteria. Criteria/LimitsAnalysis .Anevaluationofthecriteriaandlimitsthatgoverntheprocess,procedure,  oractivity;thecostandworthofthemintime,money,orothermeasurementscales;andtheflexibilityforchangingthem(hard=notpossibletoeconomicallychange,soft=maybepossibletoeconomicallychange). FinalReport .Valuestudyreportwitheditorial,andothermodificationsdonewithrespecttothe o feedbackreceivedduringpresentations,madetothePresentationReportbasicresults. FunctionalAnalysis .Aprocessusingatwoworddefinitionofthepurposeoraffectofaparticular K{ component.Topromoteunderstandingandfacilitatevaluestudyactivities,functionsarelimitedtoanactiveverbandmeasurablenoun. FunctionLogicDiagram .Adiagramofthefunctionsthatlaysoutthepurposesbehindeach !C  functionanditsinterrelationshipwithotherfunctions.ThemostcommontypeofdiagramistheFunctionalAnalysisSystemTechnique(FAST). HigherOrderFunction .Thefunction(s)thattheentireproductmustachievetomeettheultimate # !# purposefortheprocess,procedure,oractivity. Implementation .Thesuggestedprocessidentifiedbythevaluestudyasanappropriatemeansto %"% implementaspecificvaluestudyproposal. InvolvedParties .Theowners,users,andstakeholdersthathaveaconcernintheProgram,Project, '$' orActivity,oritsfinaloutcomeproduct. LifeCycleCosts .Thetrueeconomiccostofanalternativestatedinpresentworthtermsthatusesa o)&) specifiedtimevalueofmoneyandeconomiclifeandincludesallcost(nonrecurring,recurring,annual,andanypotentialsalvagecapacity). NonRecurringCosts .Theinitialoutlayoffundsorotherresourcestoobtaintheproduct. 7,g),  PresentationReport .Valuestudyreportusedforpresentingtheresultsofthevaluestudyactivity. '-W*- Theendresultcommodityforaprocess,procedure,oractivity.&  ԍ&_  ԍ̎ Proposal .Analternativemeansidentifiedwithintheconfinesofthevaluestudytoachievethepurposefortheproduct $!* thatsatisfactorilymeetsthespecifiedcriteriaandlimits.̎ RecurringCosts .Theperiodicexpenditureoffundsorotherresourcestoensuretheproductwillsatisfactorycontinue -&]#, tofunctionduringitseconomiclife.̎ JobPlan .Theactivityplanwhichisusedineveryvaluestudy. '$. Ў Value .Theworthofaproducttotheinvolvedpartiesasitisrelatedtoitscost(monetaryandnonmonetary). (%/ Ў ValueAdded .Afeaturethatdoesnotincreasethevalueoftheproductmonetarily,butincreasestheworthofthe Q)&0 producttotheinvolvedparties.̎ ValueAnalysis .TheValueMethodologyprocessasitisusuallyappliedtoanactivityforaprocess,procedure,or *(2 repetitiveactivity.̎ ValueEngineering .TheValueMethodologyprocessasitistypicallyappliedtoanengineeringtypeapplication. q,)4 Usuallyitisconductedduringthe25percentto40percentdesignphase(conceptphase)andconsistsofacompletelyindependentteam.  _ O>DD<$.G+. 4 ( >DD g 4 O ValueMethod .Anorganized,systematiceffortdirectedatanalyzingfunctionsforthepurposeof   achievingtheessentialfunctionsatthelowestlifecyclecost. ValueMismatch .Anobserveddisparityidentifiedinthefunctionlogicdiagram,orother  procedures,betweentheapparentworthofthefunctionanditscost. ValueStudy .Aninvestigationofaspecifiedprocess,problem,procedure,activity,orproductusing   theValueMethodologyprocessforthepurposeofensuringand/orimprovingthevalueofthefinalproductforinvolvedparties. N>DDD;#  4 g >DD 4<N3)'   4<   >DDD 3             <   \      *_*+ ddX HH X "#$$_,X << +  7DDJD6"  TW7B !XBX GENERALDISCUSSIONOFVALUEMETHODPROCEDURES $T USEDINTHEVALUESTUDYPROCESS#BX X!B  # N>DDD;,`" TW  DDJD6 ^)4 N General  'W ThestudyteamusedasixphaseValueMethodjobplanforallvaluestudyoperations.ShortdescriptionsofthesixbasicValueMethodphasesandtheiroperationsare: Phase1 .InformationPhase   8  Allpossibleinformationontheprocessandoperationalfeatureswithinthescopeofthestudyarecollected,disseminated,andanalyzed.Thecomponentsmakingupthefeatures,theirfunctions,andcostsaredetermined.Thecriteriaandlimitsaffectingtheprojectorprojectsareidentified,andifnecessary,rankedand/orassignedvalues.AFunctionAnalysisSystemTechnique(FAST)diagramisgeneratedwhichshowsthe"why"and"how"and"supporting"functionsbeingperformed.Theresultsarecategorizedandassignedtofunctionsofnote.Itemsforpotentialconcentrationofstudyteameffortareidentified. ""  Phase2 .CreativityPhase 'W 8  Creativitymethodssuchas"focusedbrainstorming"and affinityproceduresareusedtogeneratethemaximumquantityofideasforconsiderationbythestudyteam.Thisphaseis alsooftenreferredtoasthe"speculationphase." ""  Phase3 .AnalysisPhase  8  Ideasgeneratedinthecreativityphaseareordered,collectedintoconceptswithsimilarfeatures,solidifiedintopotentialalternativesforproposal,andrankedusingoneofavarietyoftechniques.Themostcommontwotechniquesusedforrankingarecriteriaweightingmatrixandevaluationanalysisranking,andperformanceofthefunctiondeterminationandstudyteamconsensuspotentialversusdifficultyranking.Theresultingrankedpotentialalternativesarethenevaluatedwithregardtotheirbenefits,advantages,andrisks.Thisphaseisalsooftenreferredtoasthe"evaluationphase." ""  Phase4 .DevelopmentPhase G 8  Teammembers"champion"conceptsorareassignedconceptsthathavethebestpotentialforfurtherevaluationanddevelopmentintoviable,efficient,andcosteffectivealternativeproposals.Eachdevelopedconcept,thatiscarriedtocompletion,isanalternativeproposalthathasanexpectationofincreasingthevaluefortheclientand/orowneroftheproductorprocess. "" 8  Thedevelopmentprocessincludes,butisnotlimitedto,usingteammemberexpertise;consultationwithstaffperformingtheprojectorprocess;expertsandoutsidevendors;pollingothersbysurveyorothermeans;consultationswiththeclientand/orowner;andreviewofinformationresources(libraries,catalogs,andothermaterials).Recommendationsformethodstoimplementtheproposalsareidentified,andmethodstoresolveidentifiedpotentialproblemsaredetermined.Duringthisphase,adeterminationtodropaprocessfromfurtherconsiderationusuallyrequiresunanimousacceptancebythestudyteam. ""  Phase5 .PresentationPhase ,*- 8  Conceptsthatarefullydevelopedbythestudyteamwhichdisplayapparentaddedvalue,by&  ԍ&_  ԍmonetaryornonmonetarymeasurements,areplacedinreportformfordocumentationandpresentationasalternativeproposals.Generally,theseareconceptsthathavesufficientprojectedbenefitsthatoutweightheirpotentialdisadvantagesandrisks.Duringthisphase,conceptsthatarerecommendedasalternativeproposalsmust,generally,receiveunanimousacceptancebytheentireteambeforereportpresentationandrecommendationasanalternativevaluestudyconcept. "" ̎  _>42-+."" 4 ^)  >DDD >*e,>-ddX << X *+$$e, dd +  7DDJD6"  TW7B !XBX GENERALDISCUSSIONOFVALUEMETHODPROCEDURES $T USEDINTHEVALUESTUDYPROCESS#BX X!B ؜# W>DDDD,`" TW  DDJD6 4<W0  Somestudyteamconceptsorresultsmaybeidentifiedtobeofpotentialbenefittotheclientand/orowner,butcannotbesufficientlydevelopedwithintheconfinesofthestudytimeavailable.Alternatively,someconceptswerestudiedbutwerenotconsideredtohavestudyteamconsensus,orinsomesituations,insufficientbenefitstowarranttheirdevelopmentwhencomparedtootherpotentiallyhighervalueconceptsthatcouldbedeveloped.Suchconcepts,thatdemonstrateapotentialforaddedvalue,arepresentedasadditionalitemsrecommendedforfurtherstudy.Theseitemsmay,onoccasion,requireextensiveadditionaldevelopmentactivitiesbeyondthatavailabletothestudyteamtodetermineiftheitemsactuallydemonstratetheanticipatedaddedvalue. h$h$  Phase6 .ImplementationPhase s  8  Theowner,users,client,andotherprojectorprocesspartiestakethevaluestudyrecommendationsintoconsiderationandevaluatethemforimplementation.Thestaffcoordinatingthevaluestudyactivity,andifneeded,studyteammembers,assistandmonitortheevaluationtohelpallpartiesinimplementingtheaddedvaluefeatures.Anestimateforthefinalresolutionforthevalueofrecommendationsisestablished.Thestatusofthefinaldeterminationoftheacceptedrecommendationsandtheirestimatedaddedvaluearereportedtothecoordinatingstaffas:accepted,partiallyaccepted,or"withdrawn"duetotheacceptanceofanotherpreferredproposal.Ifaproposalisrejected,therejectionandthereasonfortherejectionarereportedtothecoordinatingstaff.Statisticsandvaluestudyactivityresultsarecompiledandreportedtoorganizationalmanagementandoversightauthorities.=31"" 4<   >DDD =*_./ dd dd ,>-$$_, +  7DDJD6"  K7B !XBX  !!B   Figure11.ValueMethodDecisionProcess#X X! ؇'##BX XXX '#(X #XXBX  ' S>DDD@,k" K  DDJD6 *S50RB>z \th `tD*@ H@Ezn hn fzn h<20z" 0 *  >DDD <#BX X#X(X A(#BZXBX   -B* HH*_ dd ./$$_,*! +  ,"  x,#BX XBZϫ)#B !XBX   SPECIALCRITERIASUMMARY * #BX X!B *#BZXBX  HDDD58x" x  PH PROJECT: LZBZUNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2#BZLZ+##BX XBZZ+#BZXBX  PDDD6;#\ P DDD OP USERS: N>DD;, O DDD6 /N#BX XBZg,#Usersconsistofunenlistedsoldiers.Primaryconcernistoimproveuponcurrentlivingconditionsfor   thesoldiers. E>DD2#  / >DD /EBZXBX  P>DD6;#@  / >DD /P CODES: N>DD;,  / >DD6 /N#BX XBZ .#USACEspecificationsandcode. E>DD2#  / >DD /EBZXBX  P>DD6;#T  / >DD /P RESTRICTIONS: N>DD;,  / >DD6 /N#BX XBZo/#Thebarracksmustbesimilarenoughtoexistingthattheappearancedoesnotdetractfromtheoverall 4  base.Designmustfollowallcodeandregulationsinregardtomilitaryfacilities. E>DD2#   / >DD /EBZXBX  P>DD6;#@ / >DD /P HISTORY:(RESPONSIBILITIES,COMMITMENTS,STATUS,ETC.) N>DD;, / >DD6 /N#BX XBZu1#Constructionofthreebarrackstobebuiltinproximitytoexisting,usedforhousingnonenlisted   soldiers. J>DDD7#  / >DD _JBZXBX 3)'@ 0 _ >DDD 3#BX XBZ[3#BZXBX *_' dd*! *!$$_,9!`` +  7DDJD6" 8x K7#BX XBZ3#B !XBX   FUNCTIONANALYSISSYSTEMTECHNIQUE(FAST)DIAGRAM#BX X!B 4#BZXBX  4 S>DDD@, " K  DDJD6 S]=TTt $ Dd4Tt ,Xl! ]#BX XBZe5#Thevaluestudyteamusedthefunctionanalysisprocesstogenerateafunctionlogicdiagram.Itisoften / referredtoasaFunctionAnalysisSystemTechnique(FAST)diagram.AFASTdiagramshowsthe  "why"and"how",and"supporting"functionsbeingperformed.ItemsforpotentialconcentrationofstudyteameffortwereidentifiedthroughtheFAST.Thesefunctionaltoolsaidedtheteaminidentifyingcrucialfeaturesthatarepivotaltomeetingrequirementsthatsupportcriticalissues(basicfunctionandcriticalpathfunctions).Italsohighlightsthosefunctionsthatmeettheactivitieslesscriticalobjectives(supportingorsecondaryfunctions).ThedevelopmentoftheFASTassiststheteaminidentifyinganypotentialvaluemismatchesandexpeditestheteamseffortsingeneratingacommonunderstandingoftheactivity'spurposesandapplicablegoverningcriteria.BZXBX  O%! 3)';&{" 0  >DDD 3  3's# FASThere     <   \    |      ,    L    l   XXH]IX@` 0Pp @ `"#TT]*_(2 dd9!`` 9!'$$_,<< , << +  0& X 0#BX XBZ :#B !XBX   EXPLANATIONOFALTERNATIVEEVALUATION <#BX X!B <#BZXBX  IDDJ8 "    [IPROJECT: ?DJD,!DDJ ?LZBZUNACCOMPANIEDENLISTEDPERSONNELHOUSING(UEPH)2#BZLZ>##BX XBZR=#BZXBX  RDD>D?# [  DJD R  GeneralDiscussion ? : g Usingtheidentifiedbasicfunction(s)shownintheFASTdiagram,thevaluestudyteamgeneratedoverLZBZUnaccompaniedEnlistedPersonnelHousing(UEPH)2#BZLZ?##BX XBZϗ>#BZXBX Ԁideasfordiscussionsandevaluations.Next,theteamevaluated S applicabilityandpotentialtomeetthebasicfunctionsandgoverningcriteriaonapass/failbasis.Asaresult,numerousideaswereanalyzedandevaluatedfurther.Aftercollectionandprocessing,fifteenoftheresultingconceptswereidentifiedforpossiblerefinementthroughfurtherstudyteaminvestigations.Arankingprocedurewasusedtoguidetheteam'seffortsontheseideas.Theseconceptswerethencombined,removed,and/oraddedtootheradditionalideasandoptionsidentifiedduringtheDevelopmentPhase(duetorefinementoftheinitialconcepts),andtheresultswereultimatelypresentedasAlternativeProposals.6,*   DD>D 6#BX XBZV@#X XXBX *r dd<<  << (2$$r,99+  5DDDD"   5fLehPn  <[{ )Hg!"$X@f #BX XXX C#B  B !XBX  !!B   DESCRIPTIONOFSELECTIONPROCESSC.E vE#X X! 8E##BX XXX WE# X XXBX  WDDDDD, "  DDDD W #BX XXX F#X XXBX ZXX UsingstandardValueMethodprocedures,thevaluestudyteamidentifiedthemorecrucialfactorsinservingthebasic o  function.Usinganinesquaresystemdefiningtheeaseofobtaining(byteammembers,projectmembers,clients,andothers)andpotentialvalueenhancement(totheowner,usersandstakeholders),theteamdeterminedaninitialpriorityrankingforeachconcept.Asaresultthisranking,conceptswereidentifiedaspriorityone(immediatedevelopmentattention),prioritytwo(developifatallpossible)andprioritythree(developiftimepermits).Conceptsnotmeetingthesecriteria,andthosethattimedoesnotpermitfurtherdevelopment,arethenbrokenintothreemajorareas:#BZZϺF# ,v&ehPn  <[{ )Hg!"p x(08"ehPn <Hg! C o& $oC W 1.Deemedasworthyofmentionasanotherconceptforfurtherconsideration(butnotstudiedduetootherhigherpotentialofotherconceptsorinsufficientexpertiseand/ortimetostudywithinconfinesofteamefforts),2.Notdeemedworthfurthereffort,and3.Discardedforcause.#BX XBZF# NDDD;#w   DDDD N B !XBX   !!B PRIORITYSELECTIONPROCESSRESULTS#X X! زL##BX XXX L#B  CnM X XXBX <20o"    DDD < *_ dd99($($_, 9-, --, -9+  5DD>>"   5ZXX  q#BZZωM#ZBZ           `    ?  Ѐ 6D>>>#U "DD>> 6Ѐ#X XZN#GBZXX  # Ѐ#X XZϖP#Q $ ЀMEπI '   Ӏ ?D>>D,! (D>>> ?#BX XXX AO# EqX XXBX ԀC ) ЀD N>D>>;#*   D>>D  N  ZXX  qE#BZZKR#ZBZ 5!+  ",   р#BZZϒS#ZBZ#X XZ:S#ZXX  " -  #z!.  $Y"/  %8#0 Ѐ 6>>>>#o&$1>D>> 6Ѐ "3 Ѐ#X XZqT#A " 4 ЀK $"6 Ѐ 6>>>D#%#7>>>> 6#BX XXX /T# EqX XXBX  5!8  8"9  ;# : L E>DD>2#>$!;  >>>D  E  ZXX  qE#BZZϒV#ZBZ O'$<  .(%=     )&> Ѐ#X XZBW#J )'?  *(@  +)A  ->>D>,*B>DD> - O'$C  R(%D Ѐ̀N ->>DDX*(F>>D> -#BX XXX W# EqX XXBX ԀH O'$G ЀF3)'R(%H    >>DD 3Forcrossreferenceandconcepttitles,seedispositionofideasandconceptssheet.#BX XXX Y#